基于等级数据的因果推断:对警察暴力事件的归因和等级投票中投票顺序效应的应用
Causal Inference with Ranking Data: Application to Blame Attribution in Police Violence and Ballot Order Effects in Ranked-Choice Voting
摘要:
虽然排名是社会科学研究的核心,但人们对如何在实验研究中分析排名数据知之甚少。本文提出了一个潜在结果框架,当结果数据是排序数据时进行因果推断。它介绍了一类因果被估量量身定制的排名结果,并开发估计和推理的方法。此外,它将框架扩展到部分排名的数据。我表明,部分排名可以被认为是一个选择问题,并提出非参数的处理效应的界限。使用的方法,我重新分析了最近的研究归咎于斯蒂芬·克拉克枪击案,发现人们对官员参与枪击事件的态度是强大的上下文信息。我还应用该框架研究了2022年三次RCV选举中的投票顺序效应,提出了RCV模式排名的新理论。最后,我提出三个应用在国际关系。
英文摘要:
While rankings are at the heart of social science research, little is known about how to analyze ranking data in experimental studies. This paper introduces a potential-outcomes framework to perform causal inference when outcome data are ranking data. It introduces a class of causal estimands tailored to ranked outcomes and develops methods for estimation and inference. Furthermore, it extends the framework to partially ranked data. I show that partial rankings can be considered a selection problem and propose nonparametric sharp bounds for the treatment effects. Using the methods, I reanalyze the recent study on blame attribution in the Stephon Clark shooting, finding that people's attitudes toward officer-involved shootings are robust to contextual information. I also apply the framework to study ballot order effects in three ranked-choice voting (RCV) elections in 2022, proposing a new theory of pattern rankings in RCV. Finally, I present three applications in international relations.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。