arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2603.27073cs.HCcs.AIcs.CY
收藏

基于语音的辩论与AI对手互动与发散性思维增加相关

Voice-based debate with an AI adversary is associated with increased divergent ideation

Management Division, Columbia Business School, Columbia University(哥伦比亚大学哥伦比亚商学院管理系)

Neelam Modi Jain, Dan J. Wang

AI总结:

研究通过分析957次开放式辩论,发现语音互动在结构上与文本互动不同,语音更冗长但有助于保持连贯性,而文本更简洁但限制了概念广度。

摘要:

关于与生成式AI互动会同质化人类认知的担忧主要基于文本互动的证据,可能混淆了AI系统与书面交流的影响。本研究检验这些模式是否依赖于交流模式而非AI本身。分析957次大学学生与知识型AI对手的开放式辩论,发现交流模式对应于话语结构的不同模式。与传统口语与书面语区分一致,语音互动显著更冗长,表现出更高的词语和短语重复率。然而,这种冗余具有功能:语音用户利用重复短语在探索更广泛想法时保持连贯性。相比之下,文本互动更注重简洁和精炼,但限制了概念的广度。这些发现表明,认为生成式AI导致认知限制的感知部分反映了通过何种媒介访问AI。

英文摘要:

Concerns that interacting with generative AI homogenizes human cognition are largely based on evidence from text-based interactions, potentially conflating the effects of AI systems with those of written communication. This study examines whether these patterns depend on communication modality rather than on AI itself. Analyzing 957 open-ended debates between university students and a knowledgeable AI adversary, we show that modality corresponds to distinct structural patterns in discourse. Consistent with classic distinctions between orality and literacy, spoken interactions are significantly more verbose and exhibit greater repetition of words and phrases than text-based exchanges. This redundancy, however, is functional: voice users rely on recurrent phrasing to maintain coherence while exploring a wider range of ideas. In contrast, text-based interaction favors concision and refinement but constrains conceptual breadth. These findings suggest that perceived cognitive limitations attributed to generative AI partly reflect the medium through which it is accessed.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑