特征向量方法的理论性质
Theoretical properties of the eigenvector method
AI总结:
本文探讨了特征向量方法的五个理论缺陷,包括右左不对称、群体不一致、偏好强度依赖、修改比较后的反直觉变化以及非帕累托效率问题。
摘要:
一种从成对比较矩阵中推导权重的经典方法是右特征向量。文献中曾指出该方法在以往几十年中存在一些潜在弱点。本章讨论了其中五个问题。首先,右左不对称源于右特征向量与逆左特征向量的差异。其次,群体不一致意味着在群体决策问题中,聚合个体权重向量的排序不一定与聚合的成对比较矩阵导出的排序一致。第三,基于右特征向量的排序可能依赖于偏好强度,这由对所有比较取正幂来表示。第四,修改特定比较后,某对象的排序位置和归一化权重可能产生反直觉的变化。第五,右特征向量未必是帕累托最优:可能存在一个支配权重向量,至少在每个成对比较上表现不差,并在至少一个位置上有改进。所有理论性质的违反均通过示例突出显示。我们还提出了若干开放性问题,以激励未来研究。
英文摘要:
A classical proposal to derive weights from a pairwise comparison matrix is the right eigenvector. The literature has identified some potential weaknesses of this method in previous decades. This chapter discusses five of these issues. First, right-left asymmetry emerges because of the difference between the right and inverse left eigenvectors. Second, group incoherence for choice means that, in group decision-making problems, the ranking given by the aggregated individual weight vectors is not guaranteed to coincide with the ranking derived from the aggregated pairwise comparison matrix. Third, the ranking based on the right eigenvector may depend on the intensity of the preferences, represented by taking a positive power of all comparisons. Fourth, both the ranking position and the normalised weight of an object might change counter-intuitively after modifying a particular comparison. Fifth, the right eigenvector is not necessarily Pareto efficient: a dominating weight vector that approximates each pairwise comparison at least as well, with an improvement in at least one position, could exist. All violations of the theoretical properties are highlighted by illustrative examples. We also present several open questions in order to inspire future research.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。