arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.15369cond-mat.stat-mech
收藏

熵无方向:一个镜像态悖论反对普遍熵增以及从原理上证明约束重塑熵分布 $P_{\infty}(S;λ)$

Entropy Has No Direction: A Mirror-State Paradox Against Universal Monotonic Entropy Increase and a First-Principles Proof that Constraints Reshape the Entropy Distribution $P_{\infty}(S;λ)$

Key Laboratory for Special Area Highway Engineering of Ministry of Education, Chang’an University(教育部特殊区域公路工程重点实验室,长安大学)

Ting Peng

AI总结:

本文通过镜像态悖论反驳普遍熵增理论,从原理上证明约束如何重塑熵分布,并结合实验与自然现象展示其应用。

摘要:

我们重新审视教科书中的熵必须增加的主张,显示在时间反演不变的微观动力学下,无法普遍地在轨迹层面或统计上断言粗粒化熵 $S(t)$ 是非递减的。核心是一个镜像态构造:对于任何微观态 $A$,构造其时间反向的伙伴 $B$(动量反转);要求 $S(t)$ 对于 $A$ 和 $B$ 都是非递减的,迫使每个时间都是 $S$ 的局部极小值,因此使 $S(t)$ 沿轨迹保持恒定。一致的画面是熵是一个随机变量,由概率分布 $P(S)$ 描述,其形状取决于约束和边界条件;基于熵的规律性是约束依赖的微观动力学的涌现总结,在实践中,人们通过操控约束和边界来实现混合、分离或自组织,而不是操控熵本身。在玻尔兹曼(粗粒化)熵的能壳上,我们从原理上推导出如何通过改变不变测度来重塑长期熵分布 $P_{\infty}(S;λ)$,通过改变哈密顿量和/或可访问的相空间。在微正则设定中,我们得到一个明确的准则:只有当所有可访问的宏观态体积被一个共同因子缩放时,$P_{\infty}^{(E)}(S;λ)$ 才能保持不变(除了平移),否则分布会结构性地改变。我们将这一框架与不对称纳米孔和分子闸门的实验、土木工程中的宏观例子(防风林、堤坝、涡旋抑制、交通流控制)以及自然现象如被引导至避雷针的闪电、雪花和矿物层生长以及超冷却水突然结晶联系起来。

英文摘要:

We revisit textbook claims that entropy must increase and show that, under time-reversal invariant microscopic dynamics, no universal trajectory-wise or statistical assertion that the coarse-grained entropy $S(t)$ is non-decreasing can hold. The core is a mirror-state construction: for any microstate $A$ one constructs its time-reversed partner $B$ (momenta inverted); requiring $S(t)$ to be non-decreasing for both $A$ and $B$ forces every time to be a local minimum of $S$ and hence makes $S(t)$ constant along the trajectory. The consistent picture is that entropy is a stochastic variable described by a probability distribution $P(S)$ whose shape depends on constraints and boundary conditions; entropy-based regularities are emergent summaries of constraint-dependent microscopic dynamics, and in practice it is constraints and boundaries -- not entropy itself -- that one manipulates to achieve mixing, separation, or self-organization. Working with Boltzmann (coarse-grained) entropy on the energy shell, we then derive from first principles how constraints reshape the long-time entropy distribution $P_{\infty}(S;λ)$ by altering the invariant measure through changes in the Hamiltonian and/or the accessible phase space. In the microcanonical setting we obtain a sharp criterion: the \emph{only} way $P_{\infty}^{(E)}(S;λ)$ can remain the same up to translation is when all accessible macrostate volumes are scaled by a common factor; otherwise the distribution changes structurally. We connect this framework to experiments on asymmetric nanopores and molecular gates, to macroscopic examples from civil engineering (windbreak forests, dikes, vortex suppression, traffic-flow control), and to natural phenomena such as lightning guided to lightning rods, snowflake and mineral-veil growth, and the sudden crystallisation of supercooled water.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑