Collective behavior is commonly attributed to direct interactions among system components. Using a minimal stochastic model, we show that higher-order collective structure can instead emerge from shared stochastic environments, even in the absence of interactions. Quantified via the O-information, environmental fluctuations induce both redundant and synergistic dependencies, with the latter occupying larger regions of the correlation space. We establish a no-go theorem showing that time-independent coupling between the system variables and a shared stochastic environment rules out synergistic higher-order behavior. Crucially, this constraint can be overcome dynamically: transitions between redundancy and synergy arise from time-dependent environmental coupling or from the nontrivial interplay between shared environments and direct interactions. Together, these results identify environmental mediation as a distinct mechanism of higher-order collective organization beyond the conventional interaction-centric paradigm.
DTU Compute, Technical University of Denmark(丹麦技术大学计算学院);Center for Social Data Science (SODAS), University of Copenhagen(哥本哈根大学社会数据科学中心);Department of Computer Science, School of Science, Aalto University(阿尔托大学理学院计算机科学系)
Collective intelligence in Massive Online Dialogues
Web 2.0技术的出现和持续发展使新的和先进的集体智慧形式以前所未有的规模成为可能,允许大量的个人集体行动并创造高质量的智力作品。然而,人们对它们如何以及何时真正促进集体智慧知之甚少。在这篇手稿中,我们提供了一个调查的自动化工具,分析话语为中心的集体智慧。通过对当前研究方向进行专题分析,确定了一系列差距和限制。