买还是建一个大语言模型:政府的决策框架
Buy versus Build an LLM: A Decision Framework for Governments
AI总结:
本文提出政府在大语言模型决策中应考虑主权、安全、成本等因素的框架,帮助确定购买或建设更适合其需求的方法。
摘要:
大语言模型(LLMs)代表了数字基础设施的新前沿,可以支持广泛的社会领域应用,从通用的公民服务到专门和敏感的国家功能。在扩大AI访问时,政府面临一系列战略选择,即购买现有服务、建设国内能力或在不同领域和用例中采用混合方法。这些是关键决策,尤其是当领先模型提供商通常是外国公司,且LLM输出越来越多地被视为公共决策和公共讨论中的可信输入。在实践中,这些决策并非旨在在所有领域强制采用单一方法;相反,国家AI战略通常是多元的,主权、商业和开源模型共存以服务于不同目的。政府可能依靠商业模型处理非敏感或商品任务,同时在关键、高风险或战略性应用中追求更大控制。本文通过评估这些选项在主权、安全、成本、资源能力、文化契合度和可持续性等维度上的情况,提供了一个战略框架,以帮助做出决策。重要的是,
英文摘要:
Large Language Models (LLMs) represent a new frontier of digital infrastructure that can support a wide range of public-sector applications, from general purpose citizen services to specialized and sensitive state functions. When expanding AI access, governments face a set of strategic choices over whether to buy existing services, build domestic capabilities, or adopt hybrid approaches across different domains and use cases. These are critical decisions especially when leading model providers are often foreign corporations, and LLM outputs are increasingly treated as trusted inputs to public decision-making and public discourse. In practice, these decisions are not intended to mandate a single approach across all domains; instead, national AI strategies are typically pluralistic, with sovereign, commercial and open-source models coexisting to serve different purposes. Governments may rely on commercial models for non-sensitive or commodity tasks, while pursuing greater control for critical, high-risk or strategically important applications. This paper provides a strategic framework for making this decision by evaluating these options across dimensions including sovereignty, safety, cost, resource capability, cultural fit, and sustainability. Importantly, "building" does not imply that governments must act alone: domestic capabilities may be developed through public research institutions, universities, state-owned enterprises, joint ventures, or broader national ecosystems. By detailing the technical requirements and practical challenges of each pathway, this work aims to serve as a reference for policy-makers to determine whether a buy or build approach best aligns with their specific national needs and societal goals.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。