arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.09636cs.CY
收藏

部署法律人工智能的权衡:来自公众意见研究的洞察以指导人工智能风险管理

Trade-Offs in Deploying Legal AI: Insights from a Public Opinion Study to Guide AI Risk Management

University of Amsterdam(阿姆斯特丹大学);UKUDLA, University of Hohenheim(霍恩海姆大学);Amsterdam School of Communication Research, University of Amsterdam(阿姆斯特丹大学);Communication Studies & Computer Science, Northwestern University(西北大学);Institute for Information Law, University of Amsterdam(阿姆斯特丹大学)

Kimon Kieslich, Sophie Morosoli, Nicholas Diakopoulos, Natali Helberger

AI总结:

本文通过公众意见研究,探讨了生成式人工智能在法律领域应用的风险与收益权衡,分析了公民对法律咨询和调解任务中使用生成式人工智能的看法。

摘要:

生成式人工智能工具越来越多地用于法律任务,包括法律研究、起草文件,甚至用于法律决策。与其他用途相比,在法律领域使用生成式人工智能带来了各种风险和益处,需要妥善管理,以确保以服务公共价值观和保护人权的方式实施。尽管欧盟要求在某些用途案例(例如法官用于司法行政)之前进行风险评估和审计,但其他用途案例并不属于《人工智能法案》的高风险分类(例如公民用于法律咨询或起草文件)。此外,当前的风险管理实践优先考虑专家对风险因素识别和优先级的判断,但没有相应的法律要求咨询受影响社区。鉴于法律部门的社会重要性以及生成式人工智能在该领域可能带来的变革性影响,生成式人工智能解决方案的可接受性和合法性也取决于公众的看法以及对公民与法律领域中使用人工智能相关风险和益处的更好理解。为此,本文呈现了来自德国公民代表样本(n=488)的数据,概述了公民对生成式人工智能用于两项法律任务(法律咨询和法律调解)的看法。具体而言,我们i)系统地映射这两种法律任务的风险和益处因素,ii)描述影响生成式人工智能在这些任务中风险接受度的预测因素,iii)突出公民在权衡风险可接受性时出现的新兴权衡主题。我们的研究结果提供了关于公民对生成式人工智能在法律领域风险管理的担忧的实证概述,突显了补充当前风险评估程序的关键主题。

英文摘要:

Generative AI tools are increasingly used for legal tasks, including legal research, drafting documents, and even for legal decision-making. As for other purposes, the use of GenAI in the legal domain comes with various risks and benefits that needs to be properly managed to ensure implementation in a way that serves public values and protect human rights. While the EU mandates risk assessment and audits before market introduction for some use cases (e.g., use by judges for administration of justice) other use cases do not fall under the AI Acts' high-risk classifications (e.g., use by citizens for legal consultation or drafting documents). Further, current risk management practices prioritize expert judgment on risk factor identification and prioritization without a corresponding legal requirement to consult with affected communities. Seeing the societal importance of the legal sector and the potentially transformative impact of GenAI in this sector, the acceptability and legitimacy of GenAI solutions also depends on public perceptions and a better understanding of the risks and benefits citizens associated with the use of AI in the legal sector. As a response, this papers presents data from a representative sample of German citizens (n=488) outlining citizens' perspectives on the use of GenAI for two legal tasks: legal consultation and legal mediation. Concretely, we i) systematically map risks and benefit factors for both legal tasks, ii) describe predictors that influence risk acceptance of the use of GenAI for those tasks, and iii) highlight emerging trade-off themes that citizens engage in when weighing up risk acceptability. Our results provides an empirical overview of citizens' concerns regarding risk management of GenAI for the legal domain, foregrounding critical themes that complement current risk assessment procedures.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑