arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.04986cs.AI
收藏

人工智能作为奇异智能:反对线性智能模型

Artificial Intelligence as Strange Intelligence: Against Linear Models of Intelligence

University of California, Riverside(加州大学河滨分校)

Kendra Chilson, Eric Schwitzgebel

AI总结:

本文提出'奇异智能'概念,反对传统线性智能模型,认为AI智能具有非线性特征,能够在不同领域展现多样能力,挑战传统评估方法。

摘要:

我们支持并扩展了苏珊·施奈德对AI进步线性模型的批评,并引入了两个新概念:'熟悉智能'和'奇异智能'。人工智能智能可能属于奇异智能,这种智能违背熟悉的能力和无能模式,某些领域拥有超人类能力,其他领域则表现低于人类,甚至在同一领域有时结合超人类洞察力与令人惊讶的错误,这些错误很少有人会犯。我们发展并捍卫了一种非线性智能模型,在这种模型中,'一般智能'不是单一能力,而是能够在广泛环境和目标中实现广泛目标的能力,这种能力无法非任意地还原为单一线性量。我们最后讨论了对抗性测试方法对评估AI能力的影响。如果AI是奇异智能,我们应期望即使最强大的系统有时也会在看似明显任务上失败。在非线性AI智能模型中,这种错误本身并不表明系统缺乏卓越的一般智能。相反,出色表现于某一类任务,如IQ测试,不能推断出超出该任务领域的广泛能力。

英文摘要:

We endorse and expand upon Susan Schneider's critique of the linear model of AI progress and introduce two novel concepts: "familiar intelligence" and "strange intelligence". AI intelligence is likely to be strange intelligence, defying familiar patterns of ability and inability, combining superhuman capacities in some domains with subhuman performance in other domains, and even within domains sometimes combining superhuman insight with surprising errors that few humans would make. We develop and defend a nonlinear model of intelligence on which "general intelligence" is not a unified capacity but instead the ability to achieve a broad range of goals in a broad range of environments, in a manner that defies nonarbitrary reduction to a single linear quantity. We conclude with implications for adversarial testing approaches to evaluating AI capacities. If AI is strange intelligence, we should expect that even the most capable systems will sometimes fail in seemingly obvious tasks. On a nonlinear model of AI intelligence, such errors on their own do not demonstrate a system's lack of outstanding general intelligence. Conversely, excellent performance on one type of task, such as an IQ test, cannot warrant assumptions of broad capacities beyond that task domain.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑