不要将限制刺激用作能量材料敏感性的度量
Stop using limiting stimuli as a measure of sensitivities of energetic materials
AI总结:
本文指出'1-In-6'测试中的限制刺激概念不明确且不可靠,提出三种替代方法以更准确评估能量材料的敏感性。
摘要:
准确估计爆炸材料的敏感性是一项可能挽救生命的任务,需要各国之间标准化的协议。全球最广泛应用的程序之一是联合国(UN)《测试标准手册》中所谓的'1-In-6'测试,该测试估计材料的'限制刺激'。在本文中,我们证明,尽管这些测试很受欢迎,但限制刺激并不是敏感性的一个明确概念,也不能提供关于材料易燃性的可靠信息。特别是,它们不允许构建置信区间来量化估计的不确定性。我们展示,继续依赖限制刺激通过1-In-6测试在能量材料研究中造成了不必要的困惑,这不仅在理论研究中,在实际安全应用中也是如此。为了解决这个问题,我们考虑了三种有根据的替代方法来替代限制刺激估计。我们比较了它们在广泛模拟研究中的表现,并将表现最好的方法应用于实际数据,估计了四硝基山梨糖醇(PETN)的摩擦敏感性。
英文摘要:
Accurately estimating the sensitivity of explosive materials is a potentially life-saving task which requires standardised protocols across nations. One of the most widely applied procedures worldwide is the so-called '1-In-6' test from the United Nations (UN) Manual of Tests in Criteria, which estimates a 'limiting stimulus' for a material. In this paper we demonstrate that, despite their popularity, limiting stimuli are not a well-defined notion of sensitivity and do not provide reliable information about a material's susceptibility to ignition. In particular, they do not permit construction of confidence intervals to quantify estimation uncertainty. We show that continued reliance on limiting stimuli through the 1-In-6 test has caused needless confusion in energetic materials research, both in theoretical studies and practical safety applications. To remedy this problem, we consider three well-founded alternative approaches to sensitivity testing to replace limiting stimulus estimation. We compare their performance in an extensive simulation study and apply the best-performing approach to real data, estimating the friction sensitivity of pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN).
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。