无意识启动的研究进展:科学家何时可以声称间接任务优势?
Advancing Research on Unconscious Priming: When can Scientists Claim an Indirect Task Advantage?
摘要:
目前的文献认为,许多认知功能可以在意识之外执行。这一观点的证据来自无意识启动。在一个典型的实验中,视觉刺激被掩蔽,这样当直接询问刺激属于两个类别中的哪一个时,参与者接近于机会。这种接近于零的敏感性被视为参与者不能有意识地报告被掩蔽刺激的类别的证据。然而,被掩蔽的刺激的类别可以间接影响对其他刺激的反应(例如,反应时间或大脑活动)。因此,启动被认为是对刺激类别仍然有一些(尽管是无意识的)敏感性的证据,从而表明意识外的处理。虽然这种“无意识启动的标准推理”已被用于许多研究中,我们表明,它是有缺陷的:敏感性没有适当地计算,从而造成错误的印象,启动表示更好的敏感性比接近零的直接歧视的敏感性。我们描述了确定敏感性的适当方法,复制了具有里程碑意义的研究的行为部分,开发了一种方法来估计已发表的研究报告的汇总统计的敏感性,并使用这种方法重新分析了15个高度有影响力的研究。结果表明,许多研究的解释需要改变,需要社会的努力,重新评估大量的文献无意识启动。这一过程将使科学家能够更多地了解无意识启动的真正边界条件,从而推进对意识的科学理解。
英文摘要:
Current literature holds that many cognitive functions can be performed outside consciousness. Evidence for this view comes from unconscious priming. In a typical experiment, visual stimuli are masked, such that participants are close to chance when directly asked to which of two categories the stimuli belong. This close-to-zero sensitivity is seen as evidence that participants cannot consciously report the category of the masked stimuli. Nevertheless, the category of the masked stimuli can indirectly affect responses to other stimuli (e.g., reaction times or brain activity). Priming is therefore seen as evidence that there is still some (albeit unconscious) sensitivity to the stimulus categories, thereby indicating processing outside consciousness. Although this "standard reasoning of unconscious priming" has been used in many studies, we show that it is flawed: Sensitivities are not calculated appropriately, hereby creating the wrong impression that priming indicated better sensitivity than the close-to-zero sensitivity of the direct discrimination. We describe the appropriate way to determine sensitivities, replicate the behavioral part of a landmark study, develop a method to estimate sensitivities for published studies from reported summary statistics, and use this method to reanalyze 15 highly influential studies. Results show that the interpretations of many studies need to be changed and that a community effort to reassess the vast literature on unconscious priming is needed. This process will allow scientists to learn more about the true boundary conditions of unconscious priming, thereby advancing the scientific understanding of consciousness.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。