arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2601.01764cs.DL
收藏

关于研究科学与政策互动的证据:对Overton索引政策文件中学术与政策引用的探索

Evidence for studying interactions between science and policy: An exploration of scholarly and policy references in Overton-indexed policy documents

Leiden University(莱顿大学);Renmin University of China(中国人民大学);Stellenbosch University(斯泰伦博斯大学)

Biegzat Murat, Zhichao Fang, Ed Noyons, Rodrigo Costas

AI总结:

本研究首次系统分析Overton中引用数据的分布,揭示其在政策指标研究中的潜力与局限性。

摘要:

Overton,一个全球政策指数,为研究科学与政策之间的互动提供了新的机会。本研究旨在表征Overton索引政策文件中学术和政策引用的存在情况,并检查其在关键文献维度上的分布,从而评估Overton作为政策指标数据源的潜力。我们分析了约1750万份Overton政策文件的数据集,纳入了诸如出版年份、政策来源、国家、语言、主题领域和政策主题等元数据。使用描述性统计来评估引用数据在这些维度上的存在和分布情况。Overton索引了大量的政策文件,并在其内部识别出相当数量的引用数据:7.7%的文件包含学术引用,10.6%的文件包含政策引用。然而,引用的存在情况在出版年份、来源类型、国家、语言、主题领域和政策主题上变化显著,表明了可能影响政策影响解释的覆盖偏差。该分析基于截至2025年6月的Overton数据库。由于Overton定期更新,索引文件和引用的分布模式可能会随时间变化。研究结果提供了关于使用Overton研究基于证据的政策制定以及在研究评估背景下评估研究成果政策采纳机会和限制的见解。这是首次大规模系统研究Overton中引用数据的分布。它为政策指标这一新兴数据源提供了基础理解,突显了其潜在应用和限制,并强调了解决当前覆盖不平衡的重要性。

英文摘要:

Overton, a global policy index, provides new opportunities to study the interactions between science and policy. This study aims to characterize the presence of scholarly and policy references in Overton-indexed policy documents and examine their distribution across key bibliographic dimensions, thereby assessing Overton's potential as a data source for policy metrics. We analyze a dataset of approximately 17.5 million policy documents from Overton, incorporating metadata such as publication year, policy source, country, language, subject area, and policy topic. Descriptive statistics are employed to assess the presence and distribution of reference data across these dimensions. Overton indexes a substantial volume of policy documents and identifies considerable reference data within them: 7.7% of documents contain scholarly references and 10.6% contain policy references. However, the presence of references varies significantly across publications years, source types, countries, languages, subject areas, and policy topics, indicating coverage biases that may affect interpretations of policy impact. The analysis is based on the Overton database as of June 2025. As Overton is regularly updated, the distribution patterns of indexed documents and references may evolve over time. The findings offer insights into the opportunities and constraints of using Overton for investigating evidence-based policymaking and for assessing the policy uptake of research outputs in the context of research evaluation. This is the first large-scale study to systematically examine the distribution of reference data in Overton. It contributes a foundational understanding of this emerging source for policy metrics, highlighting both its potential applications and limitations, and underlining the importance of addressing current coverage imbalances.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑