MEVIR 2框架:一种基于美德的道德-知识论人类信任决策模型
The MEVIR 2 Framework: A Virtue-Informed Moral-Epistemic Model of Human Trust Decisions
AI总结:
MEVIR 2框架通过美德理论和道德知识论模型,解释人类信任决策的极化现象,并为设计促进理性推理的决策支持系统提供理论基础。
摘要:
MEVIR 2框架创新并改进了我们在极化信息环境中理解信任决策的方式。不同于经典模型假设理想理性,MEVIR 2认识到人类信任源于三个相互作用的基础:如何程序性地处理证据、作为知识代理的美德理论,以及由进化合作MAC模型和文化价值观扩展道德基础理论塑造的道德直觉。这解释了为什么不同的人会发现不同的权威、事实和权衡具有吸引力。MEVIR 2的关键创新引入了“真理部落”TTs——稳定社区,共享一致的程序性、美德和道德知识论特征。这些不仅仅是意识形态群体,而是内部一致的“信任网状结构”集群,在部落边界之间相互不理解。该框架区分了真理承载者和真理制造者,表明分歧往往源于对使命题为真的现实方面有根本不同观点。疫苗接种强制令和气候政策的案例研究展示了不同道德配置如何导致人们选择不同的权威、证据标准和信任锚点,构建出不同的道德知识论世界。该框架将认知偏差重新解释为知识论美德的失败,并为设计决策支持系统提供了基础,这些系统可以增强元认知、使信任过程透明,并促进在分裂社区中更审慎的推理。MEVIR 2因此提供了描述性力量来理解极化现象,并为弥合知识论分歧提供了规范指导。
英文摘要:
The MEVIR 2 framework innovates and improves how we understand trust decisions in our polarized information landscape. Unlike classical models assuming ideal rationality, MEVIR 2 recognizes that human trust emerges from three interacting foundations: how we process evidence procedurally, our character as epistemic agents virtue theory, and our moral intuitions shaped by both evolutionary cooperation MAC model and cultural values Extended Moral Foundations Theory. This explains why different people find different authorities, facts, and tradeoffs compelling. MEVIR 2's key innovation introduces "Truth Tribes" TTs-stable communities sharing aligned procedural, virtue, and moral epistemic profiles. These arent mere ideological groups but emergent clusters with internally coherent "trust lattices" that remain mutually unintelligible across tribal boundaries. The framework incorporates distinctions between Truth Bearers and Truth Makers, showing disagreements often stem from fundamentally different views about what aspects of reality can make propositions true. Case studies on vaccination mandates and climate policy demonstrate how different moral configurations lead people to select different authorities, evidential standards, and trust anchors-constructing separate moral epistemic worlds. The framework reinterprets cognitive biases as failures of epistemic virtue and provides foundations for designing decision support systems that could enhance metacognition, make trust processes transparent, and foster more conscientious reasoning across divided communities. MEVIR 2 thus offers both descriptive power for understanding polarization and normative guidance for bridging epistemic divides.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。