数学焦虑与联想知识结构在心理学专业学生中相互交织,但在GPT-3.5和GPT-4o等大型语言模型中并非如此
Math anxiety and associative knowledge structure are entwined in psychology students but not in Large Language Models like GPT-3.5 and GPT-4o
AI总结:
本研究基于行为forma mentis网络框架对比心理学学生与GPT模型,发现学生的数学焦虑与概念联想结构紧密交织,而GPT因模拟网络差异无法复现该模式,凸显了理解概念感知对管理数学焦虑的重要性。
摘要:
数学焦虑给大学心理学专业学生带来了重大挑战,影响了他们的职业选择和整体身心健康。本研究采用基于行为forma mentis网络(即映射个体如何构建联想知识结构及概念情感感知的认知模型)的框架,来探索与数学和焦虑相关的概念在感知与联想上的个体和群体差异。我们进行了4项实验,涉及来自2个样本的心理学本科生(n1 = 70,n2 = 57),并与GPT模拟的学生(GPT-3.5:n2 = 300;GPT-4o:n4 = 300)进行了对比。实验1、2和3利用个体层面的网络特征来预测数学焦虑量表中数学焦虑及其各维度(观察性、社交性和评估性)的心理测量分数。实验4侧重于从真实学生、GPT-3.5和GPT-4o的网络中提取的群体层面感知。结果表明,在学生中,“anxiety”的积极效价评分和较高的网络度,加上对“math”的消极评分,能够预测较高的总体和评估性数学焦虑。相比之下,由于模拟网络和心理测量分数与人类相比存在差异,这些模型在基于GPT的数据上不起作用。这些结果也与在模拟和真实学生的高/低子群体构建STEM概念的语义和情感方式上发现的差异相一致。高数学焦虑的学生集体以一种情感极化的方式构建了“anxiety”,而低数学焦虑学生的消极感知中则没有这种情况。“Science”被评为积极,但与对“math”的消极感知形成对比。这些发现强调了理解概念感知和联想在管理学生数学焦虑方面的重要性。
英文摘要:
Math anxiety poses significant challenges for university psychology students, affecting their career choices and overall well-being. This study employs a framework based on behavioural forma mentis networks (i.e. cognitive models that map how individuals structure their associative knowledge and emotional perceptions of concepts) to explore individual and group differences in the perception and association of concepts related to math and anxiety. We conducted 4 experiments involving psychology undergraduates from 2 samples (n1 = 70, n2 = 57) compared against GPT-simulated students (GPT-3.5: n2 = 300; GPT-4o: n4 = 300). Experiments 1, 2, and 3 employ individual-level network features to predict psychometric scores for math anxiety and its facets (observational, social and evaluational) from the Math Anxiety Scale. Experiment 4 focuses on group-level perceptions extracted from human students, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4o's networks. Results indicate that, in students, positive valence ratings and higher network degree for "anxiety", together with negative ratings for "math", can predict higher total and evaluative math anxiety. In contrast, these models do not work on GPT-based data because of differences in simulated networks and psychometric scores compared to humans. These results were also reconciled with differences found in the ways that high/low subgroups of simulated and real students framed semantically and emotionally STEM concepts. High math-anxiety students collectively framed "anxiety" in an emotionally polarising way, absent in the negative perception of low math-anxiety students. "Science" was rated positively, but contrasted against the negative perception of "math". These findings underscore the importance of understanding concept perception and associations in managing students' math anxiety.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。