From Birdwatch to Community Notes, from Twitter to X: four years of community-based content moderation
School of Mathematics and Statistics, University College Dublin(都柏林大学学院数学与统计学院);Institute for Theoretical Physics, Technical University of Berlin(柏林工业大学理论物理研究所);SPICED Academy(SPICED学院);School of Social Sciences and Philosophy, Trinity College Dublin(都柏林三一学院社会科学与哲学学院);School of Computer Science, University College Dublin(都柏林大学学院计算机科学学院);School of Sociology, University College Dublin(都柏林大学学院社会学院);Faculty of Arts and Humanities, Technological University Dublin(都柏林理工大学人文艺术学院)
Saeedeh Mohammadi, Narges Chinichian, Hannah Doyal, Anna Bertani, Kristina Skutilova, Hao Cui, Michele d'Errico, Siobhan Grayson, Taha Yasseri
Community Notes(原名Birdwatch)是X(原Twitter)于2021年1月推出的首个大规模众包内容审核举措。随着Community Notes模式在其他社交媒体平台上的普及,评估其潜在动态和有效性变得日益迫切。本文对Community Notes前四年进行了描述性研究,考察了其语言多样性、来源实践、贡献者活动、评分行为及互动网络。此外,我们发布了一个精心整理的数据集及配套源代码以支持未来研究,并回顾了先前关于Community Notes的研究。我们解析了该项目前四年的笔记和评分数据,并对所有笔记进行了语言检测。对于英文笔记,我们提取了嵌入的URL并识别了每条笔记中的讨论主题。此外,我们构建了贡献者之间的月度互动网络。描述性分析、数据集、代码和文献综述共同为推进Community Notes及更广泛的基于社区的内容审核研究奠定了基础。
英文摘要:
Community Notes (formerly known as Birdwatch) is the first large-scale crowdsourced content moderation initiative launched by X (formerly Twitter) in January 2021. As the Community Notes model gains momentum across other social media platforms, there is a growing need to assess its underlying dynamics and effectiveness. This paper provides a descriptive investigation of Community Notes during its first four years, examining its linguistic diversity, sourcing practices, Contributor activity, rating behaviour, and interaction networks. In addition, we release a curated dataset and accompanying source code to support future research, along with a review of prior research on Community Notes. We parsed Notes and ratings data from the first four years of the program and conducted language detection across all Notes. For English-language Notes, we extracted embedded URLs and identified discussion topics in each Note. Additionally, we constructed monthly interaction networks among the Contributors. Together, the descriptive analysis, dataset, code, and literature review provide a foundation for advancing research on Community Notes and community-based content moderation more broadly.
Did the Musk Takeover Boost Contentious Actors on Twitter?
Twitter被指责在其账户验证和内容审核政策方面存在自由主义偏见。埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)在收购该公司后承诺,将通过改革验证和审核政策来促进平台上的言论自由。这些事件引发了人们对有争议的行为体-特别是政治右翼-影响力上升的担忧。在本文中,我使用了一个公开发布的138 k Twitter帐户列表,这些帐户在2022年11月9日至11月11日的开放窗口期间购买了蓝色支票验证。我从一个有政治争议的账户样本中检索了490万条推文。然后,我比较了马斯克收购前后有争议的用户帖子的参与度。我发现,在马斯克被收购后的一段时间里,岗位参与度大幅增加。蓝色勾选验证后无额外增加。我解释的调查结果与活动的增加,由一个新的同情用户群。
Community Moderation and the New Epistemology of Fact Checking on Social Media
University of Copenhagen(哥本哈根大学);Massachusetts Institute of Technology(麻省理工学院);Indian Institute of Technology Delhi(德里印度理工学院);Full Fact(事实核查机构);University of Southern California(南加州大学);Technical University of Darmstadt(达姆施塔特技术大学);University of Oxford(牛津大学);The University of Melbourne(墨尔本大学);University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign(伊利诺伊大学厄巴纳-香槟分校);Newtrales(新特拉尔斯);Indiana University(印第安纳大学);EURECOM(EURECOM研究所);Mohamed bin Zayed University of Artificial Intelligence(穆罕默德·本·扎耶德人工智能大学);Pagella Politica/Facta