arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2502.20971cs.SI
收藏

基于关键词的网络中构建决策的影响:一项实证评估

Implications of construction decisions in keyword-based networks: an empirical assessment

James Nevin, Salvatore Flavio Pileggi, Michael Lees, Paul Groth

AI总结:

本文通过两个案例研究实证评估了基于关键词的复杂网络中数据预处理决策对分析结果的影响,发现常用指标高度敏感,强调需透明报告数据来源和预处理决策。

摘要:

在线持续生成的大量数据为识别和分析社会各领域的趋势提供了机会。例如,在线社交媒体数据常被用来分析群体的非正式互动、观点和情感。此外,文献计量数据可用于研究科学研究中更为正式的趋势。分析此类复杂半结构化数据的一种流行方法是基于关键词或概念提取构建复杂网络。然而,此类基于关键词的复杂网络数据通常以预处理形式共享,关于其构建过程的信息很少。实际上,从原始数据构建复杂网络时,关键决策通常是在早期阶段做出的,这些决策可能对后续分析和解释产生重大影响。在本文中,我们通过两个不同的案例研究来强调结果对数据预处理决策的敏感性,这两个案例研究使用了从底层半结构化数据构建的网络。实验表明,许多常用指标对数据预处理具有高度敏感性。这些结果证明了透明报告数据来源和预处理决策的必要性。

英文摘要:

The large amounts of data continuously generated online offer opportunities to identify and analyse trends in various aspects of society. For instance, data from online social media are frequently used as a means of analysing informal interactions, opinions, and feelings of groups of people. Additionally, bibliometric data can be used to investigate more formal trends that occur in scientific research. A popular approach to analysing such complex semi-structured data is the construction of complex networks based on keywords or concept extraction. However, such keyword-based complex network data are often shared in a preprocessed form, with little information about the underlying process used to construct it. Indeed, key decisions are normally made at an early stage in the construction of complex networks from raw data, and can have a significant impact on subsequent analysis and interpretation. In this paper, we highlight the sensitivity of results to data preprocessing decisions by looking at two different case studies which employ networks constructed from underlying semi-structured data. The experiments conducted show high sensitivity to data preprocessing for many commonly adopted metrics. These results demonstrate the need for transparent reporting of data lineage and preprocessing decisions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑