团队规模及其对颠覆性指数的负面影响
Team Size and Its Negative Impact on the Disruption Index
AI总结:
本研究通过分析6500万个项目,进一步证实团队规模与颠覆性指数之间存在负相关关系,并指出5年短窗口会误判该关系,小团队需十年以上才能展现长期颠覆性潜力。
摘要:
随着科学从 lone geniuses(孤独天才)时代过渡到协作团队时代,大型团队是否能够维持个人的创造力并持续推动创新这一问题变得愈发重要。我们先前的研究通过分析半个世纪以来涵盖论文、专利和软件的 6500 万个项目,首次揭示了团队规模与 Disruption Index(颠覆性指数,一种基于网络的创新指标)之间的负相关关系。这项工作在科学界引发了关于 Disruption Index 在捕捉团队规模对创新影响时的稳健性的激烈争论。在此,我们提供额外证据表明,即使考虑了参考文献长度、引用影响和历史时间等因素,团队规模与颠覆性之间的负向联系依然成立。我们进一步展示了用于衡量颠覆性的狭窄 5 年窗口如何将这种关系误呈现为正向,从而低估了小团队的长期颠覆性潜力。就像“sleeping beauties(睡美人)”一样,小团队需要十年或更长时间才能看到他们对科学的变革性贡献。
英文摘要:
As science transitions from the age of lone geniuses to an era of collaborative teams, the question of whether large teams can sustain the creativity of individuals and continue driving innovation has become increasingly important. Our previous research first revealed a negative relationship between team size and the Disruption Index-a network-based metric of innovation-by analyzing 65 million projects across papers, patents, and software over half a century. This work has sparked lively debates within the scientific community about the robustness of the Disruption Index in capturing the impact of team size on innovation. Here, we present additional evidence that the negative link between team size and disruption holds, even when accounting for factors such as reference length, citation impact, and historical time. We further show how a narrow 5-year window for measuring disruption can misrepresent this relationship as positive, underestimating the long-term disruptive potential of small teams. Like "sleeping beauties," small teams need a decade or more to see their transformative contributions to science.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。