arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2501.06873econ.GNcs.CLcs.IRcs.SIq-fin.ECstat.ME
收藏

经济学中的因果主张

Causal Claims in Economics

CEPR Paris Symposium(CEPR巴黎研讨会);Metascience(元科学);NetSciSci(网络科学);EAYE;Groningen;AYEW;ZBW;MPWZ-CEPR Text-As-Data(MPWZ-CEPR文本作为数据);PolMeth;Leibniz Open Science(莱布尼茨开放科学);Causal Data Science Meeting(因果数据科学会议)

Prashant Garg, Thiemo Fetzer

AI总结:

本研究通过构建证据注释的主张图,分析经济学论文中因果关系的演变及其对学术影响力的影响。

摘要:

随着经济学的发展,一个关键瓶颈是将论文中所声称的内容以可比、可聚合的形式表示出来。我们引入了带有证据注释的主张图,将每篇论文映射到一个由标准化经济概念(节点)和陈述关系(边)组成的有向网络中,每条边都标记有证据基础,包括是否由因果推断设计或非因果证据支持。通过一个结构化的多阶段人工智能工作流程,我们为1980年至2023年间44852篇经济学论文构建了主张图。因果边的比例从1990年的7.7%上升到2020年的31.7%。因果叙述结构和因果新颖性的度量与前五名的出版物和长期引用呈正相关,而非因果的对应关系则较弱或为负相关。

英文摘要:

As economics scales, a key bottleneck is representing what papers claim in a comparable, aggregable form. We introduce evidence-annotated claim graphs that map each paper into a directed network of standardized economic concepts (nodes) and stated relationships (edges), with each edge labeled by evidentiary basis, including whether it is supported by causal inference designs or by non-causal evidence. Using a structured multi-stage AI workflow, we construct claim graphs for 44,852 economics papers from 1980-2023. The share of causal edges rises from 7.7% in 1990 to 31.7% in 2020. Measures of causal narrative structure and causal novelty are positively associated with top-five publication and long-run citations, whereas non-causal counterparts are weakly related or negative.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑