arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2501.01897cs.HCcs.CY
收藏

ChatGPT的建议无论是否有理由都会驱动道德判断

ChatGPT's advice drives moral judgments with or without justification

Sebastian Kruegel, Andreas Ostermaier, Matthias Uhl

AI总结:

实验发现用户对聊天机器人道德建议的采纳与建议是否提供理由无关,建议成为逃避道德困境的廉价途径,因此需结合伦理素养与数字素养加以应对。

摘要:

为什么用户会遵循聊天机器人的道德建议?聊天机器人并不是权威的道德顾问,但它可以生成看似合理的论证。然而,我们在一项实验中发现,用户遵循有理由的建议并不比无理由的建议更迅速。不过,如果我们将建议归因于一位道德顾问而非聊天机器人,这一结论同样成立。因此,建议似乎为用户提供了一种逃避道德困境的廉价方式。这是一个聊天机器人并未引发、但却加剧的问题,因为它们使建议变得极易获取。我们得出结论:除了数字素养之外,还需要伦理素养来保护用户免受聊天机器人道德建议的影响。

英文摘要:

Why do users follow moral advice from chatbots? A chatbot is not an authoritative moral advisor, but it can generate seemingly plausible arguments. Users do not follow reasoned more readily than unreasoned advice, though, we find in an experiment. However, this is also true if we attribute advice to a moral advisor, not a chatbot. Hence, it seems that advice offers users a cheap way to escape from a moral dilemma. This is a concern that chatbots do not raise, but they exacerbate it as they make advice easily accessible. We conclude that it takes ethical in addition to digital literacy to harness users against moral advice from chatbots.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑