论两阶段模型的福利(不)相关性
On the Welfare (Ir)Relevance of Two-Stage Models
AI总结:
本文研究两阶段选择模型的福利相关性问题,揭示部分模型因偏好识别原理缺陷导致无法用于福利分析,实验表明其显示偏好密度远低于理性选择,并指出问题根源在于第一阶段建模方法而非模型本身。
摘要:
在两阶段选择模型中,决策者首先将给定菜单进行初选,然后应用其偏好。我们表明,这类模型中的相当一部分在偏好识别(福利相关性)方面遇到了严重问题,因此无法用于福利分析。我们根据这些模型的显示偏好原理对其进行分类,并揭示了我们认为导致其识别问题根源的原理。将我们的分析应用于实验数据时,我们观察到,在理性选择下被显示偏好于另一备选项的备选项中,有一半在该类模型的任何成员下都被显示为不偏好于任何备选项。此外,文献中确立的特定模型的福利相关性要差得多。福利相关性最高的模型产生的显示偏好关系的平均密度为2%(45种可能的比较中有1种被显示),而理性选择的平均密度为63%(45种可能的比较中有28种被显示)。我们论证了该问题并非两阶段模型的固有特征,而是出在文献中对第一阶段建模的方法上。
英文摘要:
In a two-stage model of choice a decision maker first shortlists a given menu and then applies her preferences. We show that a sizeable class of these models run into significant issues in terms of identification of preferences (welfare-relevance) and thus cannot be used for welfare analysis. We classify these models by their revealed preference principles and expose the principle that we deem to be the root of their identification issue. Taking our analysis to an experimental data, we observe that half of the alternatives that are revealed preferred to another under rational choice are left revealed preferred to nothing for any member of this class of models. Furthermore, the welfare-relevance of the specific models established in the literature are much worse. The model with the highest welfare-relevance produces a revealed preference relation with the average density of 2% (1 out of 45 possible comparisons revealed), while rational choice does 63% (28 out of 45 possible comparisons). We argue that the issue is not an inherent feature of two-stage models, and rather lies in the approach with which the first stage is modelled in the literature.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。