arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2410.02110cs.AIcs.CLcs.LG
收藏

LLM能否可靠地模拟人类学习者行为?面向开放式学习环境的模拟创作框架

Can LLMs Reliably Simulate Human Learner Actions? A Simulation Authoring Framework for Open-Ended Learning Environments

University of Florida(佛罗里达大学);University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign(伊利诺伊大学厄巴纳-香槟分校)

Amogh Mannekote, Adam Davies, Jina Kang, Kristy Elizabeth Boyer

AI总结:

针对LLM模拟人类学习者行为不可靠的问题,提出Hyp-Mix模拟创作框架,通过组合可测试假设开发评估模拟,在物理学习环境中验证GPT-4 Turbo能保持校准行为,首次证明LLM可模拟开放式交互学习环境中的真实行为。

摘要:

模拟学习者行为有助于在部署前对开放式交互学习环境进行压力测试并构建新适应方案的原型。尽管近期研究表明使用大型语言模型(LLM)模拟人类行为具有潜力,但由于关键局限性,此类方法尚未超越初步的概念验证阶段。首先,LLM对微小的提示变化高度敏感,这引发了对其在没有大量提示工程的情况下能否泛化到新场景的疑问。此外,表面上成功的结果往往不可靠,这要么是因为领域专家无意中引导LLM产生预期结果,导致自我实现的预言;要么是因为LLM在训练数据中遇到过高度相似的场景,这意味着模型可能不是在模拟行为,而是在重复记忆的内容。为了应对这些挑战,我们提出了Hyp-Mix,这是一个模拟创作框架,允许专家通过组合关于学习者行为的可测试假设来开发和评估模拟。在物理学习环境中测试该框架时,我们发现GPT-4 Turbo即使在底层学习者模型发生变化时也能保持校准行为,这提供了LLM可用于在开放式交互学习环境中模拟真实行为的首个证据,这是有用的LLM行为模拟的必要前提。

英文摘要:

Simulating learner actions helps stress-test open-ended interactive learning environments and prototype new adaptations before deployment. While recent studies show the promise of using large language models (LLMs) for simulating human behavior, such approaches have not gone beyond rudimentary proof-of-concept stages due to key limitations. First, LLMs are highly sensitive to minor prompt variations, raising doubts about their ability to generalize to new scenarios without extensive prompt engineering. Moreover, apparently successful outcomes can often be unreliable, either because domain experts unintentionally guide LLMs to produce expected results, leading to self-fulfilling prophecies; or because the LLM has encountered highly similar scenarios in its training data, meaning that models may not be simulating behavior so much as regurgitating memorized content. To address these challenges, we propose Hyp-Mix, a simulation authoring framework that allows experts to develop and evaluate simulations by combining testable hypotheses about learner behavior. Testing this framework in a physics learning environment, we found that GPT-4 Turbo maintains calibrated behavior even as the underlying learner model changes, providing the first evidence that LLMs can be used to simulate realistic behaviors in open-ended interactive learning environments, a necessary prerequisite for useful LLM behavioral simulation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑