arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2408.13236cs.SI
收藏

数百万人如何大规模协调:Reddit r/place三个版本中的参与、协作与冲突

How Millions Coordinate at Scale: Engagement, Collaboration, and Conflict in Three Editions of Reddit r/place

Rice University(莱斯大学)

Yutong Wu, Arlei Silva

AI总结:

研究Reddit r/place三个版本中数百万用户的参与、协作与冲突,通过纵向跨版本分析及引入可扩展动态聚类框架,发现各版本有反复出现的组织模式,如参与集中、联盟效率低等,且联盟结果难基于状态特征预测。

摘要:

大规模对等生产环境由分散协调、平台设计和资源潜在冲突之间的复杂相互作用塑造。在线基础设施虽能实现大规模协作,但也会带来协调挑战和参与者间的争议互动。Reddit的r/place实验提供了独特的社会技术环境来研究三个不同版本(2017年、2022年和2023年)中的这些动态。通过让数百万参与者在有限共享数字画布上更新像素时进行协作和竞争,产生了包含数亿次多天行动的细粒度痕迹。本文研究了r/place内参与、协作和冲突如何演变。首先对2017年、2022年和2023年活动中的参与和协作模式进行纵向跨版本分析。其次引入基于图的可扩展动态聚类框架并应用于2017年活动以从行为交互日志重建联盟轨迹。研究发现各版本存在反复出现的组织模式:尽管有个体速率限制,参与仍高度集中于少数参与者;较大联盟协调效率低且参与者人均活动中位数低;事件过程中成功越来越集中于大型协作组。对恢复的联盟轨迹分析还表明,在事件大部分时间里,基于状态特征难以预测联盟结果,凸显了r/place中协作生产的动态性和争议性。

英文摘要:

Mass peer-production environments are shaped by a complex interplay between decentralized coordination, platform design, and potential conflict over resources. While online infrastructures enable large-scale collaboration, they can also introduce coordination challenges and contested interactions among participants. The Reddit r/place experiment provides a unique socio-technical setting for studying these dynamics across three distinct editions (2017, 2022, and 2023). By allowing millions of participants to collaborate and compete as they update pixels on a finite shared digital canvas, the events generated fine-grained traces comprising hundreds of millions of actions taken over multiple days. In this paper, we examine how participation, collaboration, and conflict evolve within r/place. First, we conduct a longitudinal, cross-edition analysis of engagement and collaboration patterns across the 2017, 2022, and 2023 events. Second, to investigate collaborative activity beyond surviving final artifacts, we introduce a scalable graph-based dynamic clustering framework and apply it to the 2017 event to reconstruct coalition trajectories from behavioral interaction logs, enabling the analysis of both persistent and transient efforts. Our findings reveal recurring organizational patterns across editions: participation remains highly concentrated to few participants despite individual rate-limiting constraints, larger coalitions exhibit both greater coordination inefficiencies and lower median per-participant activity, while still success increasingly concentrates within large collaborative groups over the course of an event. Analysis of recovered coalition trajectories further shows that coalition outcomes are difficult to predict based on state characteristics during much of the event, highlighting the dynamic and contested nature of collaborative production in r/place.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑