arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2408.08846cs.CY
收藏

当信任是零和博弈:自动化对认知能动性的威胁

When Trust is Zero Sum: Automation Threat to Epistemic Agency

Emmie Malone, Saleh Afroogh, Jason DCruz, Kush R Varshney

AI总结:

本研究指出自动化即便未造成失业也会削弱劳动者认知能动性、带来认知伤害,提出对抗式协作方案,兼顾岗位保留与认知伤害、人机信任分配问题的解决。

摘要:

AI研究者与伦理学家长期担忧自动化对人类尊严、自主性以及与工作绑定的个人价值感构成的威胁。通常,针对该问题的解决方案聚焦于减少自动化导致的失业数量、对失业人员进行再培训,或是缓解失业带来的社会后果。然而,即便在劳动者保住工作的情况下,他们在岗位中的能动性也可能被严重削弱。例如,人类员工或许会与AI协同工作,但却不被允许自主决策,或是必须咨询AI并与AI达成一致后才能做出决策。这是一种认知伤害(若这种伤害基于身份偏见而分配,则可能构成不公)。它削弱了人类能动性(限制了人们独立行动的能力),并且未能认可劳动者作为合格专家的认知能动性。在这种情况下,劳动者并未获得他们理应得到的信任。这意味着即便所有人都保住了工作,人类尊严相关的问题依然存在。此外,以保住岗位为核心的解决方案,比如设计算法与人类员工协同工作,反而可能加剧这类伤害。在此,我们提出一种替代性设计方案——adversarial collaboration(对抗式协作),该方案既能解决传统的自动化岗位保留问题,还能应对更深层的认知伤害问题,以及工作场所中AI与人类之间的信任分配问题。

英文摘要:

AI researchers and ethicists have long worried about the threat that automation poses to human dignity, autonomy, and to the sense of personal value that is tied to work. Typically, proposed solutions to this problem focus on ways in which we can reduce the number of job losses which result from automation, ways to retrain those that lose their jobs, or ways to mitigate the social consequences of those job losses. However, even in cases where workers keep their jobs, their agency within them might be severely downgraded. For instance, human employees might work alongside AI but not be allowed to make decisions or not be allowed to make decisions without consulting with or coming to agreement with the AI. This is a kind of epistemic harm (which could be an injustice if it is distributed on the basis of identity prejudice). It diminishes human agency (in constraining people's ability to act independently), and it fails to recognize the workers' epistemic agency as qualified experts. Workers, in this case, aren't given the trust they are entitled to. This means that issues of human dignity remain even in cases where everyone keeps their job. Further, job retention focused solutions, such as designing an algorithm to work alongside the human employee, may only enable these harms. Here, we propose an alternative design solution, adversarial collaboration, which addresses the traditional retention problem of automation, but also addresses the larger underlying problem of epistemic harms and the distribution of trust between AI and humans in the workplace.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑