AI researchers and ethicists have long worried about the threat that automation poses to human dignity, autonomy, and to the sense of personal value that is tied to work. Typically, proposed solutions to this problem focus on ways in which we can reduce the number of job losses which result from automation, ways to retrain those that lose their jobs, or ways to mitigate the social consequences of those job losses. However, even in cases where workers keep their jobs, their agency within them might be severely downgraded. For instance, human employees might work alongside AI but not be allowed to make decisions or not be allowed to make decisions without consulting with or coming to agreement with the AI. This is a kind of epistemic harm (which could be an injustice if it is distributed on the basis of identity prejudice). It diminishes human agency (in constraining people's ability to act independently), and it fails to recognize the workers' epistemic agency as qualified experts. Workers, in this case, aren't given the trust they are entitled to. This means that issues of human dignity remain even in cases where everyone keeps their job. Further, job retention focused solutions, such as designing an algorithm to work alongside the human employee, may only enable these harms. Here, we propose an alternative design solution, adversarial collaboration, which addresses the traditional retention problem of automation, but also addresses the larger underlying problem of epistemic harms and the distribution of trust between AI and humans in the workplace.
Who Acts, Who Knows, Who Answers? A Corpus-Assisted Discourse Analysis of Agency, Epistemic Responsibility, and Accountability in Generative AI Higher Education Research
AI-Augmented Inquiry and Regulation in Hybrid Systems: A Control Allocation Architecture for Preserving Epistemic Agency in Hybrid Human-AI Cognition
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München(慕尼黑大学);Leibniz-Insitut für Wissensmedien(莱布尼茨知识媒体研究所);University of Tübingen(蒂宾根大学);The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill(北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校);Saarland University(萨尔兰大学);Heidelberg University of Education(海德堡教育大学)
Agentic AI and Pedagogical Best Practice: The Tension Between Automation and Learning
Graduate School of Informatics, Kyoto University(京都大学情报学研究科);College of Information Science and Engineering, Ritsumeikan University(立命馆大学信息科学工程学院);Academic Center for Computing and Media Studies, Kyoto University(京都大学计算与媒体研究学术中心)
Vibe Compiler: A Research-Logic Synthesis Tool That Runs without Prompt Engineering -Toward Enhancing Metacognition for Sustaining Agency in the Age of Generative AI-