映射基础模型的个人、社会和生物圈影响
Mapping the individual, social, and biospheric impacts of Foundation Models
AI总结:
本文针对AI治理过度关注技术安全与推测性风险而忽视现实社会伦理挑战的问题,提出一个批判性框架,识别14类风险与危害,并按个人、社会和生物圈影响进行映射,以指导推进负责任AI的干预措施。
摘要:
为应对基础模型、大型语言模型和生成式AI的快速推出与大规模商业化,新兴研究正揭示这些技术对社会产生的 myriad 影响。此类研究范围广泛,涵盖生成歧视性、虚假和有毒输出,侵犯隐私与版权,到不公正地剥削劳动力与自然资源。然而,全球北方一些最著名的AI治理倡议(如英国AI安全峰会和G7广岛进程)却并非如此,这些倡议影响了国际上关于AI治理的对话。尽管有大量警示案例和算法危害证据,AI治理话语仍持续过度强调安全的技术问题以及全球灾难性或生存风险。这种狭隘的焦点往往将注意力从当前AI应用粗放式工业化带来的紧迫社会与伦理挑战上转移开。为解决现实后果与推测性风险之间的这种可见性差距,本文提供了一个批判性框架,以考量基础模型和生成式AI的社会、政治和环境维度。我们识别了14类风险与危害,并根据其个人、社会和生物圈影响进行映射。我们认为,这种新颖的类型学提供了一个整合视角,以应对基础模型及其下游应用最紧迫的负面影响。最后,我们提出建议,说明如何利用该类型学指导技术与规范性干预,以推进负责任的AI。
英文摘要:
Responding to the rapid roll-out and large-scale commercialization of foundation models, large language models, and generative AI, an emerging body of work is shedding light on the myriad impacts these technologies are having across society. Such research is expansive, ranging from the production of discriminatory, fake and toxic outputs, and privacy and copyright violations, to the unjust extraction of labor and natural resources. The same has not been the case in some of the most prominent AI governance initiatives in the global north like the UK's AI Safety Summit and the G7's Hiroshima process, which have influenced much of the international dialogue around AI governance. Despite the wealth of cautionary tales and evidence of algorithmic harm, there has been an ongoing over-emphasis within the AI governance discourse on technical matters of safety and global catastrophic or existential risks. This narrowed focus has tended to draw attention away from very pressing social and ethical challenges posed by the current brute-force industrialization of AI applications. To address such a visibility gap between real-world consequences and speculative risks, this paper offers a critical framework to account for the social, political, and environmental dimensions of foundation models and generative AI. We identify 14 categories of risks and harms and map them according to their individual, social, and biospheric impacts. We argue that this novel typology offers an integrative perspective to address the most urgent negative impacts of foundation models and their downstream applications. We conclude with recommendations on how this typology could be used to inform technical and normative interventions to advance responsible AI.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。