arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2407.01765stat.MEstat.AP
收藏

配对整群随机实验中基于设计的处理效应估计通用框架

A General Framework for Design-Based Treatment Effect Estimation in Paired Cluster-Randomized Experiments

California Polytechnic State University(加州州立理工大学);Worcester Polytechnic Institute(伍斯特理工学院);University of Michigan(密歇根大学)

Charlotte Z. Mann, Adam C. Sales, Johann A. Gagnon-Bartsch

AI总结:

针对配对整群随机实验,提出一个基于设计的平均个体效应估计通用框架,阐明点估计的偏差-方差权衡,强调协变量调整的优势,并通过模拟研究比较不同估计量性能。

摘要:

配对整群随机实验(pCRTs)在教育项目影响评估试验中很常见。尽管常见,但关于如何分析这种随机化设计以估计平均处理效应,却出人意料地没有明确共识。由于配对集群产生的依赖性,方差估计也变得复杂。因此,我们旨在为pCRTs的不同估计策略提供直观且实用的比较,以指导实践者选择策略。为此,我们提出了一个基于设计的pCRTs平均个体效应估计通用框架。该框架为点估计的偏差-方差权衡提供了新颖且直观的视角,并强调了协变量调整对pCRTs估计的益处。除了提供pCRTs估计的通用框架外,我们提出的点和方差估计量支持固定样本无偏估计,其精度与常见回归模型相当,并提供保守方差估计。通过基于一项教育效能试验的模拟研究,我们比较了所回顾的点估计量和方差估计量的性能。我们的分析和模拟研究为实践中分析pCRTs时选择点和方差估计量提供了依据。

英文摘要:

Paired cluster-randomized experiments (pCRTs) are common in education program impact evaluation trials. Although common, there is surprisingly no clear consensus regarding how to analyze this randomization design to estimate average treatment effects. Variance estimation is also complicated due to the dependency created through pairing clusters. Therefore, we aim to provide an intuitive and practical comparison between different estimation strategies for pCRTs to inform practitioners' choice of strategy. To this end, we present a general framework for design-based estimation of an average individual effect in pCRTs. This framework offers a novel and intuitive view on the bias-variance trade-off between point estimators and emphasizes the benefits of covariate adjustment for estimation with pCRTs. In addition to providing a general framework for estimation with pCRTs, the point and variance estimators we present support fixed-sample unbiased estimation with similar precision to a common regression model and conservative variance estimation. Through simulation studies based on an educational efficacy trial, we compare the performance of the point and variance estimators reviewed. Our analysis and simulation studies inform the choice of point and variance estimators for analyzing pCRTs in practice.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑