arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2407.00400cs.CYstat.ML
收藏

自动化决策系统中反歧视法的形式化构建

Formalising Anti-Discrimination Law in Automated Decision Systems

Holli Sargeant, Måns Magnusson

AI总结:

针对现有机器学习公平性范式在法律适配性上的三类缺陷,本文提出基于英国反歧视法的决策论框架与“条件估计奇偶性”指标,结合真实案例验证了其在检测、缓解非法歧视上的作用,为相关从业者提供合规指导。

摘要:

随着机器学习模型被用于受法律保护场景下的高风险决策,算法歧视成为一个关键问题。尽管针对算法偏见与歧视的大量研究推动了公平性指标的发展,但若干关键法律问题在实践中仍未得到解决。本文指出了当前机器学习公平性范式的三个核心缺陷:(1)狭隘地将预测或结果差异作为歧视证据;(2)缺乏对估计误差的细致评估,且假设真实因果结构与数据生成过程是已知的;(3)以美国为基础的分析占据绝对主导,这无意中引发了其他司法辖区对合法建模实践的一些误解。为填补这些空白,我们提出了一个基于英国反歧视法的新型决策论框架,该法具有全球影响力,且与欧洲及英联邦法律体系高度契合。我们提出了“条件估计奇偶性”(conditional estimation parity)指标,该指标考虑了估计误差与底层数据生成过程,符合英国法律标准。我们将该形式化方法应用于一个真实的算法歧视案例,展示了如何协调技术推理与法律推理以检测并缓解非法歧视。我们的研究成果为机器学习从业者、政策制定者与法律学者提供了切实可行、有法律依据的指导,助力其开发具备法律稳健性的非歧视性自动化决策系统。

英文摘要:

Algorithmic discrimination is a critical concern as machine learning models are used in high-stakes decision-making in legally protected contexts. Although substantial research on algorithmic bias and discrimination has led to the development of fairness metrics, several critical legal issues remain unaddressed in practice. The paper addresses three key shortcomings in prevailing ML fairness paradigms: (1) the narrow reliance on prediction or outcome disparity as evidence for discrimination, (2) the lack of nuanced evaluation of estimation error and assumptions that the true causal structure and data-generating process are known, and (3) the overwhelming dominance of US-based analyses which has inadvertently fostered some misconceptions regarding lawful modelling practices in other jurisdictions. To address these gaps, we introduce a novel decision-theoretic framework grounded in anti-discrimination law of the United Kingdom, which has global influence and aligns closely with European and Commonwealth legal systems. We propose the "conditional estimation parity" metric, which accounts for estimation error and the underlying data-generating process, aligning with UK legal standards. We apply our formalism to a real-world algorithmic discrimination case, demonstrating how technical and legal reasoning can be aligned to detect and mitigate unlawful discrimination. Our contributions offer actionable, legally-grounded guidance for ML practitioners, policymakers, and legal scholars seeking to develop non-discriminatory automated decision systems that are legally robust.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑