arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2406.09840physics.flu-dyn
收藏

自由空气条件下 RANS 与 DDES 方法在高升力 NASA CRM 上的敏感性

Sensitivities of Free-Air RANS and DDES Methods on the High-Lift NASA CRM

Markus Zauner, Andrea Sansica, Tomoaki Matsuzaki, David James Lusher, Atsushi Hashimoto

AI总结:

针对 NASA CRM-HL 高升力构型,本文系统比较稳态/非稳态 RANS 与 DDES 在自由空气条件下对湍流模型、初始化、网格和收敛的敏感性,表明近失速需采用尺度解析方法。

摘要:

为缩短未来飞机的上市时间,在制造飞行试验原型机之前准确预测飞行包线至关重要。高升力预测研讨会(HLPW)系列旨在围绕 NASA 的高升力版通用研究模型(CRM-HL),评估当前 CFD 技术的数值预测能力。本工作为这些协作努力作出贡献,量化了基于 RANS 的稳态、非稳态以及混合 RANS/LES 尺度解析方法的敏感性。内容涵盖自由空气条件下与湍流模型选择、初始化策略、网格分辨率和迭代收敛相关的不确定性。在接近失速时,不同湍流模型和初始化策略得到的 RANS 结果呈现很大离散,而迭代收敛在当前模拟中似乎不那么关键。即使采用大型网格,稳态和非稳态 RANS 模拟也无法预测 CLmax 附近正确的流动物理。然而,延迟分离涡模拟(DDES)与风洞实验相比表现出良好精度,并以约 5% 的误差预测了 CLmax。与稳态 RANS 相比,DDES 的计算成本高出一个数量级,即十倍。文中分享了所得经验和潜在的最佳实践策略,以帮助未来研究。虽然在较低迎角下建议采用使用 SA 模型的热启动 RANS 模拟,但在接近失速时则需要尺度解析方法。

英文摘要:

To reduce the time-to-market of future aircraft, it is crucial to predict the flight envelope accurately before building prototypes for flight tests. The High-Lift Prediction Workshop (HLPW) series aims to assess the numerical prediction capability of current CFD technology considering NASA's high-lift version of the Common Research Model (CRM-HL). The present work contributes to these collaborative efforts, quantifying sensitivities for RANS-based steady, unsteady, and hybrid RANS/LES scale-resolving approaches. Uncertainties associated with the choice of turbulence model, initialization strategies, grid resolution, and iterative convergence at free-air conditions are covered. Near stall, a large spread of RANS results was observed for different turbulence models and initialization strategies, while iterative convergence appeared less crucial for the present simulations. Steady and unsteady RANS simulations were unable to predict the correct flow physics near CLmax, even for large grids. Delayed Detached Eddy Simulations (DDES), however, showed good accuracy compared with wind-tunnel experiments and predicted CLmax with an error of around 5%. Compared to steady RANS, the computational cost of DDES was a factor of ten higher. Lessons learned and potential best-practice strategies are shared to aid future studies. While warm-started RANS simulations using SA models are recommended at lower angles of attack, scale-resolving methods are required near stall.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑