arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2404.04006cs.CRcs.HC
收藏

从理论到理解:差分隐私与 $k$-匿名的比较研究

From Theory to Comprehension: A Comparative Study of Differential Privacy and $k$-Anonymity

Saskia Nuñez von Voigt, Luise Mehner, Florian Tschorsch

AI总结:

本文通过数学定义、隐私风险转化和随机响应三种解释方式,比较用户对差分隐私与 $k$-匿名隐私保护的理解,发现风险模型和随机响应模型能提升理解,而 $k$-匿名仍更易理解。

摘要:

$\varepsilon$-差分隐私这一概念被广泛用于为个人提供可量化的隐私。然而,目前尚不清楚应如何解释一个差分隐私机制在给定 $\varepsilon$ 时所提供的隐私保护水平。在本研究中,我们关注用户对差分隐私机制所提供隐私保护的理解。为此,我们研究了解释差分隐私所提供隐私保护的三种变体:(1)原始数学定义;(2)将 $\varepsilon$ 转化为具体隐私风险;(3)使用随机响应技术的解释。我们将用户采用这些解释模型时对隐私保护的理解,与其对作为可理解性基线的 $k$-匿名隐私保护的理解进行比较。研究结果表明,隐私风险模型和基于随机响应的模型提升了参与者对差分隐私保护的理解。此外,我们的结果证实了如下直觉:$k$-匿名所提供的隐私保护更易于理解。

英文摘要:

The notion of $\varepsilon$-differential privacy is a widely used concept of providing quantifiable privacy to individuals. However, it is unclear how to explain the level of privacy protection provided by a differential privacy mechanism with a set $\varepsilon$. In this study, we focus on users' comprehension of the privacy protection provided by a differential privacy mechanism. To do so, we study three variants of explaining the privacy protection provided by differential privacy: (1) the original mathematical definition; (2) $\varepsilon$ translated into a specific privacy risk; and (3) an explanation using the randomized response technique. We compare users' comprehension of privacy protection employing these explanatory models with their comprehension of privacy protection of $k$-anonymity as baseline comprehensibility. Our findings suggest that participants' comprehension of differential privacy protection is enhanced by the privacy risk model and the randomized response-based model. Moreover, our results confirm our intuition that privacy protection provided by $k$-anonymity is more comprehensible.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑