arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2403.00814cs.IRcs.CYcs.HC
收藏

基于用户决策过程的性别偏见法律案例检索系统

Gender Biased Legal Case Retrieval System on Users' Decision Process

Ruizhe Zhang, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Yueyue Wu, Beining Wang

AI总结:

本文通过72名法律背景参与者的模拟法官实验,检验法律案例检索结果中的被告性别偏见是否影响量刑认知,结果显示该影响并不显著。

摘要:

在过去十年中,法律案例检索已成为法律从业者工作的重要组成部分。在法律案例检索过程中,搜索引擎从海量数据中检索若干相关案例并提供给用户。然而,这些案例是否存在性别偏见,以及这种偏见是否会影响用户的认知,目前尚不确定。我们设计了一种新的用户实验框架,以模拟法官阅读相关案例的过程。实验邀请了72名具有法律事务背景的参与者。参与者被要求模拟法官角色,对3个指定案件进行法律案例检索,并确定这些案件中被告的量刑。任务案件和相关案件中被告的性别均经过编辑,以便从统计上衡量法律案例检索结果中的性别偏见对参与者认知的影响。结果表明,法律案例检索结果中的性别偏见并未对法官的认知产生显著影响。

英文摘要:

In the last decade, legal case search has become an important part of a legal practitioner's work. During legal case search, search engines retrieval a number of relevant cases from huge amounts of data and serve them to users. However, it is uncertain whether these cases are gender-biased and whether such bias has impact on user perceptions. We designed a new user experiment framework to simulate the judges' reading of relevant cases. 72 participants with backgrounds in legal affairs invited to conduct the experiment. Participants were asked to simulate the role of the judge in conducting a legal case search on 3 assigned cases and determine the sentences of the defendants in these cases. Gender of the defendants in both the task and relevant cases was edited to statistically measure the effect of gender bias in the legal case search results on participants' perceptions. The results showed that gender bias in the legal case search results did not have a significant effect on judges' perceptions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑