arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2402.15364cs.CYquant-ph
收藏

模型与其计算机实现是否等价?

Is a model equivalent to its computer implementation?

Beatrix C. Hiesmayr, Marc-Thorsten Hütt

AI总结:

本文探讨计算机实现与数学模型是否等价,指出实现隐含假设可能削弱因果联系,代码发布未必促进可复现性,并强调AI及量子计算带来的新挑战。

摘要:

数学建模领域的一个近期趋势是在发布研究成果的同时公开计算机代码。本文探讨一个形式化问题:计算机实现在何种意义上区别于数学模型,以及是否确实存在区别。我们认为,尽管实现模型具有便利性,但实现过程中隐含了一组假设,以至于即使在广泛使用的模型中,(形式化)数学模型与结果集合之间的因果联系也不再确定。此外,代码发布常被视为可复现研究的重要贡献,但我们提出在某些情况下可能恰恰相反。关于这一主题的新视角源于一个加速发展的趋势:在某些研究分支中,仅使用实现模型,例如人工智能(AI)。随着量子计算机的出现,我们认为在模型与实现的区分上将产生全新的挑战。

英文摘要:

A recent trend in mathematical modeling is to publish the computer code together with the research findings. Here we explore the formal question, whether and in which sense a computer implementation is distinct from the mathematical model. We argue that, despite the convenience of implemented models, a set of implicit assumptions is perpetuated with the implementation to the extent that even in widely used models the causal link between the (formal) mathematical model and the set of results is no longer certain. Moreover, code publication is often seen as an important contributor to reproducible research, we suggest that in some cases the opposite may be true. A new perspective on this topic stems from the accelerating trend that in some branches of research only implemented models are used, e.g., in artificial intelligence (AI). With the advent of quantum computers we argue that completely novel challenges arise in the distinction between models and implementations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑