arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2402.01427cs.CL
收藏

多样性对群体决策的影响

The effect of diversity on group decision-making

University of Cambridge(剑桥大学);University of Sheffield(谢菲尔德大学)

Georgi Karadzhov, Andreas Vlachos, Tom Stafford

AI总结:

本文基于 DeliData 的500段群体对话,从群体规模、初始观点池和讨论内容三方面度量认知多样性,发现更高认知多样性 consistently 关联更成功的群体审议。

摘要:

我们探讨认知多样性的不同方面及其对群体审议成功的影响。为评估这一点,我们使用来自在线小型群体讨论 Wason 卡片选择任务的 500 段对话——即 DeliData 语料库。借助该语料库,我们开展定量分析,评估三种不同的认知多样性度量。首先,我们分析群体规模作为多样性代理指标的影响。其次,我们评估初始观点池规模的影响。最后,我们通过分析被讨论的解决方案、讨论模式以及对话式探询如何改善这些特征,来考察讨论内容。尽管群体素有放大偏见的名声,我们表明,小型群体能够通过对话克服直觉偏见并改善个体决策。在大样本和不同操作化方式下,我们一致发现,更高的认知多样性与更成功的群体审议相关。用于分析的代码和数据可在仓库获取:https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24。

英文摘要:

We explore different aspects of cognitive diversity and its effect on the success of group deliberation. To evaluate this, we use 500 dialogues from small, online groups discussing the Wason Card Selection task - the DeliData corpus. Leveraging the corpus, we perform quantitative analysis evaluating three different measures of cognitive diversity. First, we analyse the effect of group size as a proxy measure for diversity. Second, we evaluate the effect of the size of the initial idea pool. Finally, we look into the content of the discussion by analysing discussed solutions, discussion patterns, and how conversational probing can improve those characteristics. Despite the reputation of groups for compounding bias, we show that small groups can, through dialogue, overcome intuitive biases and improve individual decision-making. Across a large sample and different operationalisations, we consistently find that greater cognitive diversity is associated with more successful group deliberation. Code and data used for the analysis are available in the repository: https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑