野外论证的多样性:从假设和定义到Reddit“改变我的观点”中的因果关系和轶事
The Diversity of Argument-Making in the Wild: from Assumptions and Definitions to Causation and Anecdote in Reddit's "Change My View"
摘要:
人们会提出什么样的论点,它们对他人有什么影响?对论证的规范性约束与哲学本身一样古老,但人们对实践中论证的多样性知之甚少。我们使用NLP工具从Reddit网站“Change My View”(r/CMV)中提取论证模式。这揭示了六种不同的论证模式:不仅是熟悉的演绎和归纳形式,而且还有关于定义、相关性、可能性和原因以及个人经验的论证。来自r/CMV的数据也揭示了功效的差异:个人经历以及在较小程度上关于因果关系和例子的争论最有可能改变一个人的观点,而关于相关性的争论最少。最后,我们的方法揭示了用户之间的梯度参数决策偏好:一个双轴模型,“个人-客观”和“具体-抽象”,可以解释近80%的个人之间的策略方差。
英文摘要:
What kinds of arguments do people make, and what effect do they have on others? Normative constraints on argument-making are as old as philosophy itself, but little is known about the diversity of arguments made in practice. We use NLP tools to extract patterns of argument-making from the Reddit site "Change My View" (r/CMV). This reveals six distinct argument patterns: not just the familiar deductive and inductive forms, but also arguments about definitions, relevance, possibility and cause, and personal experience. Data from r/CMV also reveal differences in efficacy: personal experience and, to a lesser extent, arguments about causation and examples, are most likely to shift a person's view, while arguments about relevance are the least. Finally, our methods reveal a gradient of argument-making preferences among users: a two-axis model, of "personal--impersonal" and "concrete--abstract", can account for nearly 80% of the strategy variance between individuals.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。