足够公平?当前实现公平算法要求的局限性图谱
Fair Enough? A map of the current limitations of the requirements to have fair algorithms
AI总结:
本文指出仅要求公平算法本身缺乏可操作性,梳理了社会对自动化决策系统的公平需求与现实含义间的脱节,并指出需解决的关键开放问题以赋予公平具体含义。
摘要:
近年来,人工智能以及更广泛的自动化决策系统在使用和效率上的提升,带来了对这类系统相关风险日益增加且受欢迎的关注。其中一种风险是,许多这类系统通过学习数据来调整和优化决策,而这些数据中存在的偏见和不公正差异可能会被延续甚至放大。这种认识一方面促使多个科学社区提出越来越合适的方法来评估、量化并尽可能缓解此类偏见和差异;另一方面,它也促使包括政策制定者在内的更多社会阶层呼吁公平算法。我们认为,尽管目前正在进行许多优秀的跨学科研究,但仍然根本缺乏一种认识,即拥有公平算法本身几乎是一个毫无意义的要求,需要补充许多额外的社会选择才能使其具有可操作性。也就是说,社会对自动化决策系统的要求与这种要求在现实场景中的实际含义之间存在脱节。在这项工作中,我们概述了这种脱节的关键特征,并指出了一系列我们作为社会必须解决的关键开放性问题,以便为自动化决策系统中日益增长的公平需求赋予具体含义。
英文摘要:
In recent years, the increase in the usage and efficiency of Artificial Intelligence and, more in general, of Automated Decision-Making systems has brought with it an increasing and welcome awareness of the risks associated with such systems. One of such risks is that of perpetuating or even amplifying bias and unjust disparities present in the data from which many of these systems learn to adjust and optimise their decisions. This awareness has on the one hand encouraged several scientific communities to come up with more and more appropriate ways and methods to assess, quantify, and possibly mitigate such biases and disparities. On the other hand, it has prompted more and more layers of society, including policy makers, to call for fair algorithms. We believe that while many excellent and multidisciplinary research is currently being conducted, what is still fundamentally missing is the awareness that having fair algorithms is per se a nearly meaningless requirement that needs to be complemented with many additional social choices to become actionable. Namely, there is a hiatus between what the society is demanding from Automated Decision-Making systems, and what this demand actually means in real-world scenarios. In this work, we outline the key features of such a hiatus and pinpoint a set of crucial open points that we as a society must address in order to give a concrete meaning to the increasing demand of fairness in Automated Decision-Making systems.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。