arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2308.02899econ.EM
收藏

非平行趋势下交错采纳设计中的处理效应

Treatment Effects in Staggered Adoption Designs with Non-Parallel Trends

Brantly Callaway, Emmanuel Selorm Tsyawo

AI总结:

本文提出在交错处理采纳且未处理潜在结果遵循交互固定效应模型时,利用处理时点变异构造额外矩条件来识别因果效应参数,无需大量时间期数或额外排除性限制。

摘要:

本文考虑在交错处理采纳设定中识别和估计因果效应参数的问题,即研究者拥有面板数据且处理时点在不同单位间存在差异。我们考虑未处理潜在结果可能在不同组别之间随时间呈现非平行趋势的情形。这意味着诸如双重差分等主流方法的识别假设不再成立。我们主要关注未处理潜在结果由交互固定效应模型生成的情形,并证明处理时点的变异提供了额外的矩条件,可用于恢复一大类目标因果效应参数。我们的方法利用处理时点的变异,既不需要(i)大量的时间期数,也不需要(ii)任何额外的排除性限制。这与几乎所有关于交互固定效应模型的文献形成对比,后者至少需要上述额外条件之一。相反,我们的方法直接适用于处理时点存在变异的情形。尽管我们的主要关注点是具有交互固定效应的模型,但我们利用处理时点变异来恢复因果效应参数的思想相当具有一般性,可以适用于其他组间存在非平行趋势的设定,例如动态面板数据模型。

英文摘要:

This paper considers identifying and estimating causal effect parameters in a staggered treatment adoption setting -- that is, where a researcher has access to panel data and treatment timing varies across units. We consider the case where untreated potential outcomes may follow non-parallel trends over time across groups. This implies that the identifying assumptions of leading approaches such as difference-in-differences do not hold. We mainly focus on the case where untreated potential outcomes are generated by an interactive fixed effects model and show that variation in treatment timing provides additional moment conditions that can be used to recover a large class of target causal effect parameters. Our approach exploits the variation in treatment timing without requiring either (i) a large number of time periods or (ii) requiring any extra exclusion restrictions. This is in contrast to essentially all of the literature on interactive fixed effects models which requires at least one of these extra conditions. Rather, our approach directly applies in settings where there is variation in treatment timing. Although our main focus is on a model with interactive fixed effects, our idea of using variation in treatment timing to recover causal effect parameters is quite general and could be adapted to other settings with non-parallel trends across groups such as dynamic panel data models.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑