arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2307.08326cs.HC
收藏

从信息到选择:对决策制定可视化工具的批判性探究

From Information to Choice: A Critical Inquiry Into Visualization Tools for Decision Making

Emre Oral, Ria Chawla, Michel Wijkstra, Narges Mahyar, Evanthia Dimara

AI总结:

本研究批判性综述了可视化工具在决策过程的设计与选择阶段的支持程度,发现多数工具在可见性上表现良好但灵活性有限,且缺乏支持决策偏好的工具,为未来研究指明了方向。

摘要:

面对复杂决策时,人们通常会经历一个三阶段过程,从(1)探索和分析相关信息(情报)开始,(2)生成并探索备选方案(设计),最终(3)通过评估判别标准来选择最优决策(选择)。我们可以合理地假设,所有优秀的可视化工具都能通过支持数据探索和分析来辅助情报阶段。然而,可视化系统目前在其他决策阶段(即设计和选择)的支持程度和方式如何?为了探究这一问题,我们对决策聚焦型可视化工具进行了全面综述,检查了包括VIS、EuroVis和CHI在内的主要可视化期刊和会议的所有可用年份的出版物。我们采用了演绎编码方法和深入分析,以评估可视化工具是否以及如何支持设计和选择阶段。具体而言,我们通过(i)显示决策备选方案、标准和偏好的可见性程度,以及(ii)通过添加、修改、更改映射和过滤等交互操作来操纵决策备选方案、标准和偏好的灵活性程度,来检查每个可视化工具。我们的综述突出了机遇和挑战,并揭示了一个令人惊讶的现象:支持所有阶段的工具十分稀缺,虽然大多数工具在提供决策标准和备选方案的可见性方面表现出色,但操纵这些元素的灵活性程度往往有限,且能够容纳决策偏好及其引导的工具明显缺乏。未来研究可以探索提高灵活性的水平和多样性,探索新颖的可视化范式,增加算法支持,并通过增强的灵活性水平确保这种自动化由用户控制。

英文摘要:

In the face of complex decisions, people often engage in a three-stage process that spans from (1) exploring and analyzing pertinent information (intelligence); (2) generating and exploring alternative options (design); and ultimately culminating in (3) selecting the optimal decision by evaluating discerning criteria (choice). We can fairly assume that all good visualizations aid in the intelligence stage by enabling data exploration and analysis. Yet, to what degree and how do visualization systems currently support the other decision making stages, namely design and choice? To explore this question, we conducted a comprehensive review of decision-focused visualization tools by examining publications in major visualization journals and conferences, including VIS, EuroVis, and CHI, spanning all available years. We employed a deductive coding method and in-depth analysis to assess if and how visualization tools support design and choice. Specifically, we examined each visualization tool by (i) its degree of visibility for displaying decision alternatives, criteria, and preferences, and (ii) its degree of flexibility for offering means to manipulate the decision alternatives, criteria, and preferences with interactions such as adding, modifying, changing mapping, and filtering. Our review highlights the opportunities and challenges and reveals a surprising scarcity of tools that support all stages, and while most tools excel in offering visibility for decision criteria and alternatives, the degree of flexibility to manipulate these elements is often limited, and the lack of tools that accommodate decision preferences and their elicitation is notable. Future research could explore enhancing flexibility levels and variety, exploring novel visualization paradigms, increasing algorithmic support, and ensuring that this automation is user-controlled via the enhanced flexibility levels.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑