arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2307.05064cs.LO
收藏

稳定模态知识的接受语义

An Acceptance Semantics for Stable Modal Knowledge

Peter Hawke

AI总结:

本文针对嵌入认知可能性断言的知识归属中的逻辑难题,提出稳定接受语义,在保留知识真实性与负透明性的同时放弃逆否命题的普遍有效性。

摘要:

我们观察到一些令人困惑的语言学数据,这些数据涉及嵌入认知(不)可能性断言的普通知识归属。我们得出结论:同时支持经典逻辑和一对直觉上有吸引力的论题是站不住脚的——这两个论题分别是:知识归属总是真实的,以及一个“负透明性”论题,该论题将关于简单否定“可能”断言的知识还原为不含模态内容的认知断言。我们提出一种应对这一权衡的策略:保留真实性和(广义化的)负透明性,同时放弃逆否命题的普遍有效性。我们考察并批评了将真实性纳入域语义的各种方法,域语义是捕捉负透明性以及更一般地捕捉含认知模态语句的非经典行为的典型“信息敏感”框架。随后我们提出一种新颖的信息敏感语义,成功执行了我们所偏好的策略:稳定接受语义。

英文摘要:

We observe some puzzling linguistic data concerning ordinary knowledge ascriptions that embed an epistemic (im)possibility claim. We conclude that it is untenable to jointly endorse both classical logic and a pair of intuitively attractive theses: the thesis that knowledge ascriptions are always veridical and a `negative transparency' thesis that reduces knowledge of a simple negated `might' claim to an epistemic claim without modal content. We motivate a strategy for answering the trade-off: preserve veridicality and (generalized) negative transparency, while abandoning the general validity of contraposition. We survey and criticize various approaches for incorporating veridicality into domain semantics, a paradigmatic `information-sensitive' framework for capturing negative transparency and, more generally, the non-classical behavior of sentences with epistemic modals. We then present a novel information-sensitive semantics that successfully executes our favored strategy: stable acceptance semantics.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑