arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2307.04766cs.CLcs.AI
收藏

机器为何不理解:对 Søgaard 的回应

Why machines do not understand: A response to Søgaard

Jobst Landgrebe, Barry Smith

AI总结:

本文反驳 Søgaard 关于机器能理解语言的观点,指出其混淆了人类使用的语言与存储介质中的惰性符号序列,从而论证机器并不真正理解语言。

摘要:

一些所谓“人工智能”的辩护者相信机器能够理解语言。特别是,Søgaard 在本刊中基于以下观点论证了这一论题:(1)有语义之处就有理解;(2)机器不仅能够实现他所谓的“推理语义”,甚至能够(借助传感器输入)“学习”指称语义(Søgaard, 2022)。我们指出他的错误在于,他未能充分关注人类所使用的语言与语言存储在硬盘或图书馆书籍中时所产生的惰性符号序列之间的区别。

英文摘要:

Some defenders of so-called `artificial intelligence' believe that machines can understand language. In particular, Søgaard has argued in this journal for a thesis of this sort, on the basis of the idea (1) that where there is semantics there is also understanding and (2) that machines are not only capable of what he calls `inferential semantics', but even that they can (with the help of inputs from sensors) `learn' referential semantics \parencite{sogaard:2022}. We show that he goes wrong because he pays insufficient attention to the difference between language as used by humans and the sequences of inert of symbols which arise when language is stored on hard drives or in books in libraries.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑