arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2102.04310cs.CL
收藏

单例谬误:为什么当前对语言模型的批评没有抓住重点

The Singleton Fallacy: Why Current Critiques of Language Models Miss the Point

RISE (Research Institutes of Sweden)(瑞典国家研究院(瑞典研究所))

Magnus Sahlgren, Fredrik Carlsson

摘要:

本文讨论了当前对基于神经网络的自然语言理解(NLU)解决方案(称为语言模型)的批评。我们认为,目前的辩论大部分依赖于一个论证错误,我们将称为单例谬误:假设语言,意义和理解是单一的和统一的现象,是无法获得的(当前)语言模型。与此相反,我们将认为,有许多不同类型的语言使用,意义和理解,(当前)语言模型建立与获取和代表一种类型的语言结构的理解明确的目的。我们认为,这种结构性理解可能涵盖几种不同的模态,因此可以处理几种不同类型的意义。我们的立场是,我们目前看不出有任何理论理由说明这种结构性知识不足以算作“真正的”理解。

英文摘要:

This paper discusses the current critique against neural network-based Natural Language Understanding (NLU) solutions known as language models. We argue that much of the current debate rests on an argumentation error that we will refer to as the singleton fallacy: the assumption that language, meaning, and understanding are single and uniform phenomena that are unobtainable by (current) language models. By contrast, we will argue that there are many different types of language use, meaning and understanding, and that (current) language models are build with the explicit purpose of acquiring and representing one type of structural understanding of language. We will argue that such structural understanding may cover several different modalities, and as such can handle several different types of meaning. Our position is that we currently see no theoretical reason why such structural knowledge would be insufficient to count as "real" understanding.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑