机器学习会放大房地产市场的定价错误吗?机器学习反馈环的经济学
Does Machine Learning Amplify Pricing Errors in the Housing Market? -- The Economics of Machine Learning Feedback Loops
摘要:
机器学习算法越来越多地用于对待售房屋、出租房产、出租车辆以及各种其他商品和服务进行定价或估值。基于机器学习的价格通常是由基于历史销售数据训练的复杂算法生成的。然而,向消费者显示这些价格会锚定已实现的销售价格,这反过来又会成为算法未来迭代的训练样本。这种机器学习“反馈回路”(一种间接的人类-算法交互)的经济意义仍然相对未被探索。在这项工作中,我们在住房市场的背景下开发了一个机器学习反馈回路的分析模型。我们发现,反馈循环导致机器学习算法对自己的准确性过于自信(低估了它的误差),并导致房屋卖家过度依赖可能错误的算法价格。因此,在反馈回路均衡中,销售价格可能变得完全不稳定(相对于没有ML价格干扰的真实消费者偏好)。然后,我们确定了条件(ML模型的选择,卖方特征和市场特征),在反馈回路均衡中,房屋卖方的经济回报比没有机器学习更差。我们还使用Zillow的住房市场数据对我们的分析模型的原始构建块进行了实证验证。最后,我们提出了算法纠正策略,以减轻机器学习反馈回路的影响,讨论了平台采用这些策略的激励措施,并讨论了政策制定者在监管中的作用。
英文摘要:
Machine learning algorithms are increasingly employed to price or value homes for sale, properties for rent, rides for hire, and various other goods and services. Machine learning-based prices are typically generated by complex algorithms trained on historical sales data. However, displaying these prices to consumers anchors the realized sales prices, which will in turn become training samples for future iterations of the algorithms. The economic implications of this machine learning "feedback loop" - an indirect human-algorithm interaction - remain relatively unexplored. In this work, we develop an analytical model of machine learning feedback loops in the context of the housing market. We show that feedback loops lead machine learning algorithms to become overconfident in their own accuracy (by underestimating its error), and leads home sellers to over-rely on possibly erroneous algorithmic prices. As a consequence at the feedback loop equilibrium, sale prices can become entirely erratic (relative to true consumer preferences in absence of ML price interference). We then identify conditions (choice of ML models, seller characteristics and market characteristics) where the economic payoffs for home sellers at the feedback loop equilibrium is worse off than no machine learning. We also empirically validate primitive building blocks of our analytical model using housing market data from Zillow. We conclude by prescribing algorithmic corrective strategies to mitigate the effects of machine learning feedback loops, discuss the incentives for platforms to adopt these strategies, and discuss the role of policymakers in regulating the same.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。