arXiv 2302.090452023-02-17physics.ed-ph

Comment on "How perception of learning environment predicts male and female students' grades and motivational outcomes in algebra-based introductory physics courses"

Michael B. Weissman

备注：: 9 low-density pages, 1 figure, accepted 12/6/2022 in Phys Rev Phys Educ Res but expected publication date unknown

英文摘要：

A recent paper used structural equation modeling to infer effects of gender-dependent student attitudes on several outcomes of introductory physics courses. The model used is precisely Markov equivalent to an equally plausible approximation in which a key gender-dependent coefficient in determining attitudes is indistinguishable from zero. I also argue that the qualitative framing may attribute to students motivations that actually belong to their teachers.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来，可能存在错误，请以论文正文为准。

阅读原文

阅读 PDF ↗

arXiv 页面 ↗HTML 原文 ↗

本文内容

英文摘要相关论文

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来，可能存在错误，请以论文正文为准。

继续探索

相关论文

How the learning environment predicts male and female students' motivational beliefs in algebra-based introductory physics courses

Societal stereotypes and biases pertaining to who belongs in physics and who can excel in physics can impact motivational beliefs, e.g., of women and racial and ethnic minority students in physics courses. This study investigates how the learning environment predicts male and female students' motivational beliefs including physics self-efficacy, interest, and identity at the end of year long (spanning two-semester) algebra-based introductory physics courses. These were courses at a large university in the US taken primarily by biological science majors many of whom are interested in health pro…

2020-08-05physics.ed-ph

How learning environment predicts male and female students' physics motivational beliefs in introductory physics courses

In this study, we adapt prior identity framework to investigate the effect of learning environment (including perceived recognition, peer interaction and sense of belonging) on students' physics self-efficacy, interest and identity by controlling for their self-efficacy and interest at the beginning of a calculus-based introductory physics course. We surveyed 1203 students, 35% of whom were women. We found that female students' physics self-efficacy and interest were lower than male students' at the beginning of the course, and the gender gaps in these motivational constructs became even large…

2020-07-15physics.ed-ph

The Masterclass of particle physics and scientific careers from the point of view of male and female students

With this study we tried to investigate if male and female students have a different perception of scientific careers. At the end, we would like to be able to provide hints on how to intervene to correct the path that seems to naturally bring male students towards STEM disciplines (science, technology, engineering, and math) and reject female students from them.

2016-11-16physics.ed-phphysics.soc-ph

Swimming against the tide: Gender bias in the physics classroom

This study examines physics students' evaluations of identical, video-recorded lectures performed by female and male actors playing the role of professors. The results indicate that evaluations by male students show statistically significant overall biases with male professors rated more positively than female professors. Female students tended to be egalitarian, except in two areas. Female students evaluated female professors' interpersonal/communicative skills more positively than male professors'. They evaluated female professors' scientific knowledge and skills less positively than that of…

2017-06-01physics.ed-phphysics.soc-ph

A longitudinal analysis of students' motivational characteristics in introductory physics courses: Gender differences

The lack of diversity and the under-performance of underrepresented students in STEM courses have been the focus of researchers in the last decade. In particular, many hypotheses have been put forth for the reasons for the under-representation and under-performance of women in physics. Here, we present a framework for helping all students learn in science courses that takes into account four factors: 1) characteristics of instruction and learning tools, 2) implementation of instruction and learning tools, 3) student characteristics, and 4) students' environments. While there has been much rese…

2021-02-15physics.ed-ph

How perception of being recognized or not recognized by instructors as a "physics person" impacts male and female students' self-efficacy and performance

We discuss a study in a first year college introductory physics course for physical science and engineering majors that shows that women, on average, feel less recognized by their physics instructors than men as students who can excel in physics. We also discuss how this lack of perceived positive recognition pertaining to physics can adversely affect their self-efficacy and performance in the course. We recommend that physics instructors not be parsimonious in their praise of students and make a conscious effort to positively recognize their students for their effort and progress whenever an …

2020-07-15physics.ed-ph

更多相关论文收起更多论文

Is agreeing with a gender stereotype correlated with the performance of female students in introductory physics?

Several prior studies in introductory physics have found a gender gap on conceptual assessments such as the Force Concept Inventory (FCI) and the Conceptual Survey of Electricity and Magnetism (CSEM) with male students performing better than female students. Moreover, prior studies in the context of mathematics have also found that activation of a negative stereotype about a group can lead to deteriorated performance of the stereotyped group. Here, we describe two studies in which we investigated the impact of interventions on the gender gap on the FCI and CSEM in large introductory physics co…

2020-06-26physics.ed-ph

Gender Differences in Undergraduate Physics Courses: A Comparative Study of Persistence

We have investigated the difference in persistence between male and female students while taking undergraduatephysics courses. To quantify the persistence of a certain group of students, we have defined 'persistence index' as the inverseof the decrease rate of the number of that group of students while taking a specific course. We have collected the data fromthree consecutive workshops on various topics of physics. After plotting the number of participations against the number ofdays attended, we have calculated the decrease rates and persistence indices for both male and female student groups…

2017-01-20physics.ed-ph

超越性别：社区人口统计对男女学生进入高中物理的续读率的交叉影响

Beyond gender: The intersectional impact of community demographics on the continuation rates of male and female students into high school physics

本研究利用加拿大人口普查和安大略省十一年注册数据，通过分层线性建模分析性别与社区人口统计对高中物理续读率的交叉影响，发现学校层面因素影响最大，且STEM学科不应视为同质。

2023-11-17physics.ed-phphysics.soc-ph

Preliminary evidence for available roles in mixed-gender and all-women lab groups

Group work during lab instruction can be a source of inequity between male and female students. In this preliminary study, we explored the activities male and female students take on during a lab session at a university in Denmark. Different from many studies, the class was majority-female, so three of the seven groups were all female and the rest were mixed-gender. We found that students in mixed-gender groups divide tasks in similar ways to mixed-gender groups at North American institutions, with men handling the equipment and women handling the computer more often. We also found that women …

2020-07-29physics.ed-ph

The impact of scaffolding and question structure on the gender gap

We address previous hypotheses about possible factors influencing the gender gap in attainment in physics. Specifically, previous studies claim that male advantage may arise from multiple-choice style questions, and that scaffolding may preferentially benefit female students. We claim that female students are not disadvantaged by multiple-choice style questions, and also present some alternative conclusions surrounding the scaffolding hypothesis. By taking both student attainment level and the degree of question scaffolding into account, we identify questions which exhibit real bias in favour …

2017-04-24physics.ed-ph

The impact of stereotype threat on gender gap in introductory physics

Many prior studies have found a gender gap between male and female students' performance on conceptual assessments such as the Force Concept Inventory (FCI) and the Conceptual Survey of Electricity and Magnetism (CSEM) with male students performing better than female students. Prior studies have also found that activation of a negative stereotype about a group or stereotype threat, e.g., asking test-takers to indicate their ethnicity before taking a test, can lead to deteriorated performance of the stereotyped group. Here, we describe two studies in which we investigated the gender gap on the …

2020-06-26physics.ed-ph

Gender differences in conceptual understanding of Newtonian mechanics: a UK cross-institution comparison

We present results of a combined study from three UK universities where we investigate the existence and persistence of a performance gender gap in conceptual understanding of Newtonian mechanics. Using the Force Concept Inventory, we find that students at all three universities exhibit a statistically significant gender gap, with males outperforming females. This gap is narrowed but not eliminated after instruction, using a variety of instructional approaches. Furthermore, we find that before instruction the quartile with the lowest performance on the diagnostic instrument comprises a disprop…

2012-11-16physics.ed-ph

Developing a Magnetism Conceptual Survey and Assessing Gender Differences in Student Understanding of Magnetism

We discuss the development of a research-based conceptual multiple-choice survey related to magnetism. We also discuss the use of the survey to investigate gender differences in students' difficulties with concepts related to magnetism. We find that while there was no gender difference on the pre-test, female students performed significantly worse than male students when the survey was given as a post-test in traditionally taught calculus-based introductory physics courses (similar results in both the regular and honors versions of the course). In the algebra-based courses, the performance of …

2016-02-16physics.ed-ph