直接多重打靶与直接配点法在生物力学预测仿真中表现相似
Direct multiple shooting and direct collocation perform similarly in biomechanical predictive simulations
AI总结:
本研究比较了生物力学中直接多重打靶与直接配点法在求解最优控制问题的表现,发现基于逆动力学约束的DC方法在动态一致性和收敛稳定性上更优,建议优先使用。
摘要:
直接多重打靶(DMS)和直接配点(DC)是生物力学和机器人学中求解最优控制问题(OCP)的两种常用转录方法。它们在解和速度方面很少被比较。通过在Bioptim软件中使用5种转录方法和100个初始猜测求解的5个预测仿真示例,我们发现没有一种方法能系统性地表现更好。除一个OCP外,所有方法都收敛到几乎相同的解(成本、状态和控制),后者中发现了几个局部最小值。然而,基于四阶Legendre多项式的DC总体上提供了更好的结果,特别是在动态一致性方面,优于基于四阶Runge-Kutta方法的DMS。此外,使用逆动力学表达刚体约束通常比正向动力学更快。基于逆动力学动力学约束的DC收敛到更好且变异性更小的解。因此,我们建议从这种转录方法开始求解OCP,但继续测试其他方法。
英文摘要:
Direct multiple shooting (DMS) and direct collocation (DC) are two common transcription methods for solving optimal control problems (OCP) in biomechanics and robotics. They have rarely been compared in terms of solution and speed. Through five examples of predictive simulations solved using five transcription methods and 100 initial guesses in the Bioptim software, we showed that not a single method outperformed systematically better. All methods converged to almost the same solution (cost, states, and controls) in all but one OCP, with several local minima being found in the latter. Nevertheless, DC based on fourth-order Legendre polynomials provided overall better results, especially in terms of dynamic consistency compared to DMS based on a fourth-order Runge-Kutta method. Furthermore, expressing the rigid-body constraints using inverse dynamics was usually faster than forward dynamics. DC with dynamics constraints based on inverse dynamics converged to better and less variable solutions. Consequently, we recommend starting with this transcription to solve OCPs but keep testing other methods.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。