arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2302.05708cs.HC
收藏

支架进展:结构化编辑器如何在从块过渡到文本时塑造新手错误

Scaffolding Progress: How Structured Editors Shape Novice Errors When Transitioning from Blocks to Text

Majeed Kazemitabaar, Viktar Chyhir, David Weintrop, Tovi Grossman

摘要:

从基于块的编程过渡到基于文本的编程环境可能具有挑战性,因为它需要学生学习新的程序设计语言概念。在本文中,我们确定和分类时遇到的问题,从基于块的基于文本的编程。特别是,我们调查的差异,出现在学习者使用结构化编辑器相比,非结构化编辑器。我们跟踪了26名高中生(12-16岁; M=14岁),他们从Scratch过渡到Python分为三个阶段:(i)学习Scratch,(ii)使用结构化或非结构化编辑器从Scratch过渡到Python,以及(iii)使用非结构化编辑器评估Python编码技能。我们确定了27种不同类型的问题,并表明在过渡阶段使用结构化编辑器的学习者与没有使用结构化编辑器的学习者相比,语法问题减少了4.6倍,数据类型问题减少了1.9倍。当这些学习者切换到非结构化编辑器进行评估时,他们在数据类型问题上保持了较低的比率,但面临的语法错误增加了4倍。

英文摘要:

Transitioning from block-based programming to text-based programming environments can be challenging as it requires students to learn new programming language concepts. In this paper, we identify and classify the issues encountered when transitioning from block-based to text-based programming. In particular, we investigate differences that emerge in learners when using a structured editor compared to an unstructured editor. We followed 26 high school students (ages 12-16; M=14 years) as they transitioned from Scratch to Python in three phases: (i) learning Scratch, (ii) transitioning from Scratch to Python using either a structured or unstructured editor, and (iii) evaluating Python coding skills using an unstructured editor. We identify 27 distinct types of issues and show that learners who used a structured editor during the transition phase had 4.6x less syntax issues and 1.9x less data-type issues compared to those who did not. When these learners switched to an unstructured editor for evaluation, they kept a lower rate on data-type issues but faced 4x more syntax errors.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑