arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2302.04219cs.HC
收藏

NewsComp:通过比较注释促进多样化的新闻阅读

NewsComp: Facilitating Diverse News Reading through Comparative Annotation

Md Momen Bhuiyan, Sang Won Lee, Nitesh Goyal, Tanushree Mitra

摘要:

为了支持高效、平衡的新闻消费,将来自不同来源的文章合并为一,可能通过众包,可以减轻一些障碍。然而,合并过程也可能影响注释者对内容的态度。为了验证这一理论,我们提出了比较新闻注释,即,注释一对文章之间的相似性和差异。通过开发和部署NewsComp --一个原型系统--我们进行了一个受试者之间的实验(N=109),以研究用户的注释与专家的注释相比,以及比较注释如何影响用户对文章可信度和质量的看法。我们发现,在某些情况下,比较注释可以轻微影响用户的可信度感知。虽然用户的注释与专家的注释并不相同,但他们在寻找相似之处方面比在识别不同的重要陈述方面表现出更高的精度。比较过程导致用户注意到信息放置/深度,真实性/意见程度和移情/煽动性语言使用的差异。我们讨论了未来的比较注释任务的设计的影响。

英文摘要:

To support efficient, balanced news consumption, merging articles from diverse sources into one, potentially through crowdsourcing, could alleviate some hurdles. However, the merging process could also impact annotators' attitudes towards the content. To test this theory, we propose comparative news annotation, i.e., annotating similarities and differences between a pair of articles. By developing and deploying NewsComp -- a prototype system -- we conducted a between-subjects experiment(N=109) to examine how users' annotations compare to experts', and how comparative annotation affects users' perceptions of article credibility and quality. We found that comparative annotation can marginally impact users' credibility perceptions in certain cases. While users' annotations were not on par with experts', they showed greater precision in finding similarities than in identifying disparate important statements. The comparison process led users to notice differences in information placement/depth, degree of factuality/opinion, and empathetic/inflammatory language use. We discuss implications for the design of future comparative annotation tasks.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑