使用不确定性数据包络分析比较选区
Comparing Voting Districts with Uncertain Data Envelopment Analysis
AI总结:
提出基于不确定性数据包络分析的新范式来比较选区地图,避免先验指标统一评估的缺陷,允许对每个选区分别进行最优评估,并通过公开地图验证了方法的有效性。
摘要:
不公正划分选区是当代美国社会最突出的问题之一,新选区地图的绘制及其随后的法律挑战占据了现代政治话语的很大一部分。关于可用选区的法律、社会和政治辩论需要公平的概念,这是一个 loosely characterized 但模糊的概念,一直未能精确定义。我们提出了一种比较选区地图的新范式,避免了使用先验指标统一评估地图所带来的缺陷。我们的评估方法展示了如何使用不确定性数据包络分析在多种指标上评估地图,这一策略允许对每个选区分别进行最优评估。我们在一组提议的公开地图上测试了该方法,以说明我们的评估策略。
英文摘要:
Gerrymandering voting districts is one of the most salient concerns of contemporary American society, and the creation of new voting maps, along with their subsequent legal challenges, speaks for much of our modern political discourse. The legal, societal, and political debate over serviceable voting districts demands a concept of fairness, which is a loosely characterized, but amorphous, concept that has evaded precise definition. We advance a new paradigm to compare voting maps that avoids the pitfalls associated with an a priori metric being used to uniformly assess maps. Our evaluative method instead shows how to use uncertain data envelopment analysis to assess maps on a variety of metrics, a tactic that permits each district to be assessed separately and optimally. We test our methodology on a collection of proposed and publicly available maps to illustrate our assessment strategy.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。