arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2210.05199stat.ME
收藏

从自适应设计估计心理测量函数

Estimating psychometric functions from adaptive designs

Simon Bang Kristensen, Katrine Bødkergaard, Bo Martin Bibby

AI总结:

本文研究自适应设计对心理测量函数估计的影响,发现其虽保留渐近性质但引入小样本偏差,尤其影响斜率参数,指出需在高效采样与增加样本量缓解偏差间权衡。

摘要:

自适应设计会随着信息的积累动态调整,应用自适应设计的一个后果是可能在估计中引入小样本偏差。在心理测量学和心理物理学中,一类常见研究调查受试者完成任务的能力与刺激强度的函数关系,刺激强度指任务提供的信息量或清晰度。表现与强度之间的关系由心理测量函数表示。这类实验通常应用自适应设计,利用先前的强度和表现来分配刺激强度,策略是在心理测量函数信息最大化的强度处采样。类似方案常用于药物试验,通过早期观察的剂量和反应动态分配剂量。本文研究自适应对心理测量函数统计推断的影响,重点关注估计,考虑固定和自适应设计下的参数与非参数估计,方案涵盖受试者内独立性以及通过随机效应的依赖性。我们通过分析研究这些场景,聚焦潜在类别模型推导随机效应下的结果,并通过模拟研究进行数值分析。结果表明,虽然估计量的渐近性质在自适应下得以保留,但设计的自适应性质会引入小样本偏差,尤其是在心理测量函数的斜率参数中。我们认为,这为应用自适应设计的研究带来了困境,表现为更高效采样与增加样本量以缓解小样本偏差之间的权衡。

英文摘要:

An adaptive design adjusts dynamically as information is accrued and a consequence of applying an adaptive design is the potential for inducing small-sample bias in estimates. In psychometrics and psychophysics, a common class of studies investigate a subject's ability to perform a task as a function of the stimulus intensity, meaning the amount or clarity of the information supplied for the task. The relationship between the performance and intensity is represented by a psychometric function. Such experiments routinely apply adaptive designs, which use both previous intensities and performance to assign stimulus intensities, the strategy being to sample intensities where the information about the psychometric function is maximised. Similar schemes are often applied in drug trials to assign doses dynamically using doses and responses from earlier observations. The present paper investigates the influence of adaptation on statistical inference about the psychometric function focusing on estimation, considering both parametric and non-parametric estimation under both fixed and adaptive designs in schemes encompassing within subject independence as well as dependence through random effects. We study the scenarios analytically, focussing on a latent class model to derive results under random effects, and numerically through a simulation study. We show that while the asymptotic properties of estimators are preserved under adaptation, the adaptive nature of the design introduces small-sample bias, in particular in the slope parameter of the psychometric function. We argue that this poses a dilemma for a study applying an adaptive design in the form of a trade-off between more efficient sampling and the need to increase the number of samples to ameliorate small-sample bias.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑