arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2210.03530quant-ph
收藏

波函数不可能是实波--那么我们还能谈粒子本体论吗

The Wave Function Cannot be a Real Wave Then Can We Speak of an Ontology of Particles

Sofia Wechsler

摘要:

这个波函数是不是一个通过我们仪器的物理实体?它是一个真正的波,还是仅仅是一个计算测量结果概率的数学工具?对量子力学的不同解释对这个问题给出了不同的答案。这篇文章表明,假设的波函数是一个真正的波必然与量子力学的预测矛盾,当狭义相对论调用。因此,本文集中于这样的解释,即推测在我们的装置中运动的现实是粒子,它们在波函数的约束下运动。德布罗意-玻姆解释与这幅图相匹配,它假设粒子沿着连续的轨迹运动。然而,连续轨道的想法被证明与量子预言相矛盾。因此,这里不考虑这种解释。S. Gao解释说,粒子处于永久的随机和不连续运动(RDM)中。由于它总是从一个地方跳到另一个地方,所以在某一时刻占据的位置的总集合由波函数的绝对平方给出。作为他的想法的动机,高认为,如果一个带电粒子同时在两个或更多的位置在同一时间,粒子的副本将相互排斥,破坏波函数。这里证明了量子形式主义使这种动机是错误的。虽然驳斥了这一动机,RDM的解释是在这里检查。这种解释的一对夫妇的问题进行检查,它被证明,他们不会导致任何可观察到的矛盾与QM预测,除了一个问题,似乎没有解决方案。总之,似乎没有一个广泛传播的解释质量管理是矛盾的。

英文摘要:

Is the wave function a physical reality traveling through our apparatus? Is it a real wave, or it is only a mathematical tool for calculating probabilities of results of measurements? Different interpretations of the quantum mechanics (QM) assume different answers to this question. It is shown in this article that the assumption that the wave function is a real wave entails a contradiction with the predictions of the QM, when the special relativity is invoked. Therefore, this text concentrates on interpretations which conjecture that the reality that moves in our apparatuses is particles, and they move under the constraints of the wave function. The de Broglie Bohm interpretation, which matches this picture, assumes that the particle travels along a continuous trajectory. However, the idea of continuous trajectories was proved to lead to a contradiction with the quantum predictions. Therefore this interpretation is not considered here. S. Gao conjectured that the particle is in a permanent random and discontinuous motion (RDM). As it jumps all the time from place to place, the total set of occupied positions at a certain time is given by the absolute square of the wave function. As motivation for his idea, Gao argued that if a charged particle were simultaneously in two or more locations at the same time, the copies of the particle would repel one another, destroying the wave function. It is proved here that the quantum formalism renders this motivation wrong. Although refuting this motivation, the RDM interpretation is examined here. A couple of problems of this interpretation are examined and it is proved that they do not lead to any observable contradictions with the QM predictions, except one problem which seems to have no solution. In all, it appears that none of the wide-spread interpretations of the QM is free of contradictions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑