知识生成中不确定性演化的信任校准研究综述
Trust Calibration as a Function of the Evolution of Uncertainty in Knowledge Generation: A Survey
摘要:
用户信任是设计强大的可视化分析系统的关键考虑因素,该系统可以引导用户得出合理合理的结论,尽管人类,机器和数据源引入了不可避免的偏见和其他不确定性,这些数据源绘制了知识出现的画布。在研究考虑后出现了许多因素,这些因素引入了相当大的复杂性,并加剧了我们对可视化分析系统中信任关系如何演变的理解,就像它们在智能社会技术系统中一样。然而,视觉分析系统本质上并不引发与其更简单的表兄弟完全相同的现象,也不一定是相同类型的现象。无论如何,这两个应用程序域都呈现了产生可信性需求的相同根本原因:不确定性和风险假设。此外,视觉分析系统,甚至比(传统上)倾向于在处理过程中直接人类输入和方向的智能系统更受许多认知偏见的影响,这些认知偏见进一步加剧了对可能影响用户信心的不确定性的解释,并最终影响对系统的信任。在这篇文章中,我们认为,通过信息提取和假设检验来解释数据源中不确定性的传播,对于理解用户对可视化分析系统的信任如何在其生命周期中演变是必要的,分析师对可视化参数的选择为我们提供了一种简单的方法来捕捉不确定性和认知偏差之间的相互作用,作为分析师在评估解释时执行的搜索任务。我们从视觉分析,人类认知理论和不确定性的文献中抽取了广泛的横截面,并试图综合一个有用的观点。
英文摘要:
User trust is a crucial consideration in designing robust visual analytics systems that can guide users to reasonably sound conclusions despite inevitable biases and other uncertainties introduced by the human, the machine, and the data sources which paint the canvas upon which knowledge emerges. A multitude of factors emerge upon studied consideration which introduce considerable complexity and exacerbate our understanding of how trust relationships evolve in visual analytics systems, much as they do in intelligent sociotechnical systems. A visual analytics system, however, does not by its nature provoke exactly the same phenomena as its simpler cousins, nor are the phenomena necessarily of the same exact kind. Regardless, both application domains present the same root causes from which the need for trustworthiness arises: Uncertainty and the assumption of risk. In addition, visual analytics systems, even more than the intelligent systems which (traditionally) tend to be closed to direct human input and direction during processing, are influenced by a multitude of cognitive biases that further exacerbate an accounting of the uncertainties that may afflict the user's confidence, and ultimately trust in the system. In this article we argue that accounting for the propagation of uncertainty from data sources all the way through extraction of information and hypothesis testing is necessary to understand how user trust in a visual analytics system evolves over its lifecycle, and that the analyst's selection of visualization parameters affords us a simple means to capture the interactions between uncertainty and cognitive bias as a function of the attributes of the search tasks the analyst executes while evaluating explanations. We sample a broad cross-section of the literature from visual analytics, human cognitive theory, and uncertainty, and attempt to synthesize a useful perspective.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。