arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2209.03253stat.AP
收藏

将人群水平试验作为N-of-1试验分析:在步态研究中的应用

Analyzing Population-Level Trials as N-of-1 Trials: an Application to Gait

Lin Zhou, Juliana Schneider, Bert Arnrich, Stefan Konigorski

AI总结:

本研究提出将人群水平试验重新作为N-of-1试验分析的方法,以步态为场景验证发现个体干预效应存在高度异质性,为利用人群数据探究个体因果效应提供了新思路。

摘要:

当研究参与者之间的干预效应存在异质性时,研究健康干预的个体因果效应便具有重要意义。开展N-of-1试验(即单病例随机对照试验)是开展此类分析的金标准。本研究提出一种替代方案:将已有的人群水平研究重新作为N-of-1试验进行分析,并以步态为应用场景进行说明。研究收集了16名健康年轻参与者的步态数据,采集场景涵盖疲劳与非疲劳状态,以及单任务(仅行走)和双任务(行走同时执行认知任务)条件。我们首先构建了标准的人群水平ANOVA模型,以评估不同条件下步态参数(步幅长度和步幅时间)的差异。随后,我们将每位参与者视为独立试验,通过贝叶斯线性混合模型在个体水平估计干预对步态参数的效应,并对两类分析的结果进行比较。结果显示,尽管人群水平的总体效应并不显著,但个体水平分析揭示了参与者之间存在的细微差异。所有参与者的步态参数基线值差异极大,疲劳和认知任务引发的参数变化也具有高度异质性,部分个体甚至呈现出方向相反的效应。与认知任务干预相比,疲劳干预下人群水平与个体水平分析的差异更为显著。基于实证分析结果,我们更广泛地探讨了以N-of-1试验视角重新分析人群研究的方法,并强调了重要的注意事项与前提要求。本研究鼓励未来研究利用人群水平数据探究个体效应。

英文摘要:

Studying individual causal effects of health interventions is of interest whenever intervention effects are heterogeneous between study participants. Conducting N-of-1 trials, which are single-person randomized controlled trials, is the gold standard for their analysis. In this study, we propose to re-analyze existing population-level studies as N-of-1 trials as an alternative, and we use gait as a use case for illustration. Gait data were collected from 16 young and healthy participants under fatigued and non-fatigued, as well as under single-task (only walking) and dual-task (walking while performing a cognitive task) conditions. We first computed standard population-level ANOVA models to evaluate differences in gait parameters (stride length and stride time) across conditions. Then, we estimated the effect of the interventions on gait parameters on the individual level through Bayesian linear mixed models, viewing each participant as their own trial, and compared the results. The results illustrated that while few overall population-level effects were visible, individual-level analyses showed nuanced differences between participants. Baseline values of the gait parameters varied largely among all participants, and the changes induced by fatigue and cognitive task performance were also highly heterogeneous, with some individuals showing effects in opposite direction. These differences between population-level and individual-level analyses were more pronounced for the fatigue intervention compared to the cognitive task intervention. Following our empirical analysis, we discuss re-analyzing population studies through the lens of N-of-1 trials more generally and highlight important considerations and requirements. Our work encourages future studies to investigate individual effects using population-level data.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑