arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2207.01518cs.CYcs.DL
收藏

科学编辑中的性别不平等与自我发表模式

Gender inequality and self-publication patterns among scientific editors

New York University Abu Dhabi(阿布扎比纽约大学);Aalto University(阿尔托大学);Kobe University(神户大学);Khalifa University of Science and Technology(哈利法科学与技术大学);UiT – The Arctic University of Norway(挪威北极大学)

Fengyuan Liu, Petter Holme, Matteo Chiesa, Bedoor AlShebli, Talal Rahwan

AI总结:

基于五十年间103,000名编辑和2.2亿篇论文的数据,本文揭示女性在编辑和主编中代表性远低于其在科学界的比例,并发现8%的编辑在任职后自我发表速率翻倍,男性更易出现该行为。

摘要:

学术出版是记录和传播科学发现的主要媒介,其日常运作的核心是编辑委员会。尽管编辑委员会的活动和招募过程对外部观察者往往不透明,但他们在促进公平评价和性别平等方面发挥着关键作用。关于性别不平等的文献缺乏将女性作为编辑与作为活跃科研人员之间的联系,因而未能比较这两种学术角色中的性别平衡状况。关于编辑公平性的文献同样缺乏对编辑因从事科研活动而产生利益冲突的纵向研究,这种利益冲突会激励他们加快发表自己的论文。我们利用一个涵盖五个十年、15个学科、包含103,000名编辑、2.4亿名作者和2.2亿篇出版物的数据集来填补这些空白。这一独特的数据集使我们能够比较任意年份或学科中女性编辑与女性科学家的比例。尽管女性在科学领域中的代表性已经不足(26%),但她们在编辑中的比例更低(14%),在主编中的比例尤其低(8%);缺乏具有足够长发表生涯的女性可以解释编辑中的性别差距,但无法解释主编中的性别差距,这表明可能还有其他因素在起作用。我们的数据集还使我们能够研究编辑的自我发表模式,结果显示,8%的编辑在开始担任编辑职务后不久,在自己期刊上发表论文的速率翻倍,并且这种行为在主编过度自我发表的期刊中更为突出。最后,男性比女性更有可能参与这种行为。

英文摘要:

Academic publishing is the principal medium of documenting and disseminating scientific discoveries. At the heart of its daily operations are the editorial boards. Despite their activities and recruitment often being opaque to outside observers, they play a crucial role in promoting fair evaluations and gender parity. Literature on gender inequality lacks the connection between women as editors and as research-active scientists, thereby missing the comparison between the gender balances in these two academic roles. Literature on editorial fairness similarly lacks longitudinal studies on the conflicts of interest arising from editors being research active, which motivates them to expedite the publication of their papers. We fill these gaps using a dataset of 103,000 editors, 240 million authors, and 220 million publications spanning five decades and 15 disciplines. This unique dataset allows us to compare the proportion of female editors to that of female scientists in any given year or discipline. Although women are already underrepresented in science (26%), they are even more so among editors (14%) and editors-in-chief (8%); the lack of women with long-enough publishing careers explains the gender gap among editors, but not editors-in-chief, suggesting that other factors may be at play. Our dataset also allows us to study the self-publication patterns of editors, revealing that 8% of them double the rate at which they publish in their own journal soon after the editorship starts, and this behavior is accentuated in journals where the editors-in-chief self-publish excessively. Finally, men are more likely to engage in this behaviour than women.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑