arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2205.13641stat.APcs.DL
收藏

研究补助金分配方面的性别差异-喜忧参半

Gender differences in research grant allocation -- a mixed picture

Peter van den Besselaar, Charlie Mom

摘要:

赠款分配中的性别偏见偏离了科学价值应指导赠款决定的原则。然而,大多数关于赠款分配中的性别偏见的研究都集中在成功率的性别差异上,而没有包括衡量成绩的变量。这项研究有两个主要贡献。首先,它包括几个价值变量的分析。其次,它包括在选择过程发生的面板水平上的分析,这使得能够在过程水平上更深入地研究偏差。调查结果如下:(i)在对成绩进行控制后,在分数中发现了一种一贯的性别偏见模式:妇女的分数比男子低得多。(ii)分数是两步决策过程的输入,这项研究表明,在第一次选择决定中,75%的申请被拒绝,对女性有偏见,在第二次(最终)选择决定中,对女性有偏见。(iii)在单个小组一级,分析显示了一种混合的偏见模式:在一些小组中,妇女获得赠款的几率低于男子,而在其他小组中,我们发现情况正好相反,仅次于不分性别的决策小组。(iv)在所研究的案例中,总体而言,赠款的分配似乎是平衡的。(v)小组一级的混合模式似乎与小组的组成和性别陈规定型观念的程度等特点有关。

英文摘要:

Gender bias in grant allocation is a deviation from the principle that scientific merit should guide grant decisions. However, most studies on gender bias in grant allocation focus on gender differences in success rates, without including variables that measure merit. This study has two main contributions. Firstly, it includes several merit variables in the analysis. Secondly, it includes an analysis at the panel level where the selection process takes place, and this enables to study bias more in-depth at the process level. The findings are: (i) After controlling for merit, a consistent pattern of gender bias was found in the scores: women receive significant lower grades than men do. (ii) The scores are an input into the two-step decision-making process, and this study shows bias against women in the first selection decision where 75% of the applications are rejected, and bias in favor of women in the second (final) selection decision. (iii) At the level of individual panels, the analysis shows a mixed pattern of bias: in some panels the odds for women to receive a grant are lower than for men, whereas in other panels we find the opposite, next to panels with gender-neutral decision making. (iv) In the case under study, at an aggregated level the allocation of grants seems balanced. (v) The mixed pattern at panel level seems to relate characteristics such as the panel composition, and the level of gender stereotyping.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑