刑事司法系统中的种族量刑差异和差异进展:来自联邦和州法院数据的证据
Racial Sentencing Disparities and Differential Progression Through the Criminal Justice System: Evidence From Linked Federal and State Court Data
摘要:
若干关键行为者-警察、检察官、法官-可以改变个人通过多阶段刑事司法系统的过程。我使用1994年至2010年联邦法院的相关逮捕量刑数据来研究早期阶段在估计黑人白人量刑差距时所发挥的作用。我没有发现联邦环境中样本选择的证据,这表明联邦法官对种族量刑差异负有主要责任。相比之下,我在两个不同的州法院系统的大量样本选择偏差文件。忽略选择的种族和民族量刑差距估计分别低估了15%和13%的真实差异。
英文摘要:
Several key actors -- police, prosecutors, judges -- can alter the course of individuals passing through the multi-staged criminal justice system. I use linked arrest-sentencing data for federal courts from 1994-2010 to examine the role that earlier stages play when estimating Black-white sentencing gaps. I find no evidence of sample selection at play in the federal setting, suggesting federal judges are largely responsible for racial sentencing disparities. In contrast, I document substantial sample selection bias in two different state courts systems. Estimates of racial and ethnic sentencing gaps that ignore selection underestimate the true disparities by 15% and 13% respectively.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。